As climate change accelerates, there is increasing need to understand how species and ecosystems respond to warming. The challenge we face is the huge diversity of responses among species, and their variability across biological, temporal, and spatial scales. Studies investigating thermal performance typically focus on single populations, single life stages, and/or single time points, which restrict our ability to predict how ongoing warming will shape the holistic performance of species and their ecological functions. Here, we collate empirical data from the literature on the thermal performance of five of the most impactful habitat‐modifying urchin species. Using meta‐analytic approaches, we compare thermal performance across different species, life stages, range positions, seasons, and response metrics to understand the variability inherent in their response to warming and to uncover common patterns in thermal performance measurements. Results show that thermal performance differs within species across each of these covariates; however, some common patterns emerged. An increase in thermal tolerance was observed from larval to adult life stages within each species, as well as from response metrics assessing sub‐organism (e.g. biochemical reactions rates such as respiration) to whole‐organism (e.g. grazing rates, movement) levels of biological complexity. Variation in thermal responses across range position depended on species biology and ecology. We also identified very significant knowledge gaps. Thermal performance data were typically measured using only a narrow range of covariates, limiting our capacity to interpret the broader impacts of warming on these species. Furthermore, all studies have been carried out in laboratory settings far removed from realized ecological conditions. These findings are critical to guide future work required to gain a holistic understanding of these species' response in the wild and highlight the importance of considering the variability in species performance across spatial, temporal, and biological scales to understand the impacts of warming on marine ecosystems.