In this article, we analyse a lesson on Thales’s theorem in a Chilean secondary school classroom through the combination of two theories: Mathematics Teachers’ Specialised Knowledge (ThMTSK) and Mathematical Working Spaces (ThMWS). Both theories, first separately and then in relation to one another, are used to analyse two tasks proposed by the teacher in the classroom following a cross-methodology for networking of theories. Through a single case study research design, a content analysis of the transcript of the video recording of the lesson was conducted. The joint analysis of this lesson allows us to better understand the mathematical work taking place in the classroom. In particular, the results show the scope of each model and their complementarity through the detection of meeting points and blind spots, through the role of proof, representations, and the change between geometrical and numerical work in teaching Thales’s theorem. This allows for a deeper understanding of a teacher’s practice and teaching. Ultimately, relationships between the theoretical elements of both theories are established to show their complementarity. We conclude that networking between theories can contribute to the development of these theories by raising questions that involve examining their foundations and assumptions in greater depth.
Resumen Este artículo presenta los resultados de un estudio de caso sobre el trabajo geométrico desarrollado por estudiantes en formación inicial de pedagogía en matemáticas (futuros profesores). Proponemos una tarea geométrica con uso de lápiz y papel, y una tarea en versión adaptada para ambientes tecnológicos. Los análisis se sustentan en el marco del Espacio de Trabajo Matemático (ETM), que permite profundizar en los procesos cognitivos y aspectos epistemológicos desarrollados en el trabajo. Los resultados muestran diferencias entre el ETM previsto y ETM personal de los futuros profesores participantes y el privilegio de fases de trabajo matemático específicas. Con ello, aportamos con un cuerpo de conocimiento sobre el análisis del trabajo geométrico y, con un marco teórico y metodológico que permite profundizar en el trabajo matemático de personas que resuelven tareas específicas.
This study addresses the research developed around the theory of mathematical working spaces (MWS). To this end, factors such as researchers’ country of origin are considered, as well as methodological characteristics, proposed objectives in each study, specific theoretical factors, and the links between MWS and other theoretical perspectives. This systematic review follows the guidelines stated by reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses for documenting each stage of the review. In total, 102 studies were considered from databases including Dialnet, SciElo, Scopus, and Web of Science. The results help to illustrate research trends in MWS theory, as well as the possibility of fertile ideas for new studies and future lines of research for those interested in this theoretical approach.