Jonathan W. Hak

Jonathan W. Hak

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Jonathan W. Hak

Leicester Law School, University of Leicester, Leicester, UK

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

5Years (2022-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
24 June 2024
Verified
Conference Paper
Open access
JHJonathan W. Hak
Jonathan W. Hak
We are confronted daily with images of war, conflict, and crime. While some of these images emanate from reliable sources who make their original media available to investigators and counsel, increasingly these images exist in the largely unregulated open source environment where legitimate images compete with the triple threat of AI generated synthetic content, deepfakes, and shallowfakes. How can viewers know what images to trust? Can we ascertain the truth when there is such an active movement towards misinformation and disinformation? Absent a compelling reason to disbelieve what we see, there is a commonly held default belief in the trustworthiness of what our eyes register - that 'seeing is believing'. In many cases, that belief is justified but given that images emanate from a broad range of sources, some more trustworthy than others, concerns regarding their reliability are not without foundation. Whether images are worthy of belief is a contextual consideration, dependent upon who is presenting them, their source, any narrative attached to the images, and the purpose for which they are being shown. The tendency to believe what we see reflects a general lack of critical discernment borne from underdeveloped visual literacy. Pictures do not speak for themselves and frequently require technical and interpretive assistance. Questioning the authenticity and reliability of image-based evidence is an essential step in gaining an informed understanding of what propositions images may support. Images can be intentionally manipulated or inadvertently altered in such a way as to trick or mislead viewers. The reliability of images is dependent upon how they are recorded, stored, processed, analysed, and presented for consideration. Acquiring the visual literacy needed to properly assess images is essential in searching for the truth that they may offer. In a criminal prosecution, counsel function as evidential gatekeepers. They must have a command of all the evidence to be tendered and this means they must be able to present a blueprint for determining image reliability. Evidence as to the source of the images, the photographer who recorded them, the location of the original media, any image processing or alteration that has occurred, editing, and contextual information surrounding their creation must be pursued. If the lack of some or all these foundational facts results in images that evince tenuous reliability, they will be of little value for counsel in their trial narrative, and of even less value for the court when deciding facts. Image-based evidence can be extraordinarily valuable in the search for the truth, but the current approach to this evidence is fundamentally inadequate for truth seeking purposes. The use of image-based evidence in international criminal prosecutions is at a tipping point. In his pioneering book, Image-Based Evidence in International Criminal Prosecutions: Charting a Path Forward [1], Dr. Jonathan W. Hak KC examines keys issues and considerations regarding this important source of evidence and offers strategies and recommendations for the effective use of images in criminal prosecutions. This presentation will look at selected issues and recommendations with a focus on the legal and practical considerations for the use of image-based evidence in criminal investigations and the courtroom.

21 July 2022 in Homicide Studies
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
CWChristina Witt
Christina Witt
JHJonathan W. Hak
Jonathan W. Hak
EBErin Gibbs Van Brunschot
Erin Gibbs Van Brunschot
GAGraham Abela
Graham Abela
In 2020, a research study was conducted surveying homicide investigators and managers within the province of Alberta (Canada). This study provided investigator insight and knowledge of current issues impacting investigations, focusing on issues related to the law and prosecutions. Specifically, two key Supreme Court of Canada decisions were identified as having significant impact on homicide investigations. Limiting factors regarding the law and prosecutions included case law developments impacting privacy issues, warrant requirements, disclosure, and prosecution timelines, which continue to challenge homicide investigators. Recommendations are made to assist investigators and managers in navigating these legal changes.

9 April 2026 in European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
ARAndrea Macarulla Rodriguez
Andrea Macarulla Rodriguez
LULuis Unzueta
Luis Unzueta
Martin MullinsMartin Mullins
Martin Mullins
JHJonathan W. Hak
Jonathan W. Hak
SGSean Gaines
Sean Gaines