Philippe Moussay

Philippe Moussay

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Philippe Moussay

Bureau International des Poids et Mesures, Pavillon de Breteuil, F-92312 Sèvres, France

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

15Years (2012-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 January 2023 in Metrologia
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JVJ Viallon
J Viallon
TCT Choteau
T Choteau
EFE Flores
E Flores
FIF Idrees
F Idrees
PMP Moussay
P Moussay
ICI Chubchenko
I Chubchenko
Main text: The pilot study CCQM-P204 was aimed at evaluating the level of compatibility of laboratories' measurement capabilities to value assign isotope ratios in samples of pure CO2 gas, expressed as isotope delta values relative to the relevant international scale: δ13CVPDB and δ18OVPDB-CO2. Pure CO2 gas samples were prepared by the BIPM in batches of 10 samples of the same gas and circulated to participants for measurement. Each participant received four samples of CO2 with a different nominal δ13CVPDB value: −1 ‰; −9 ‰; −35 ‰; and −42 ‰. The BIPM was also responsible for evaluating the homogeneity and stability of the samples. The co-coordinator IAEA received one sample per batch to confirm the batch-to-batch homogeneity. Within-batch and between-batch inhomogeneity was assessed and found to be negligible in comparison to the spread of results reported by participants. Participants used the analytical technique of their choice to measure the isotope delta values. They were requested to report the measurement results together with detailed information on their traceability, measurement methods and data treatment. Results of the comparison were to be compiled by the BIPM and evaluated jointly by the BIPM and the IAEA. The majority of participants reported results using DI-IRMS, and those that reported results based on laser spectroscopy techniques showed a very similar dispersion of results as for DI-IRMS, although generally with greater uncertainty. A total of nineteen participants reported their measurements, with two of them reporting results with different reference materials to provide more insight into the traceability of the measurements. The results were reported with traceability to three different VPDB scale realizations, notably VPDB, VPDB-LSVEC and VPDB2020, with 8, 7 and 6 results reported respectively for each of these. Participants agreed that results based on VPDB and VPDB2020 scale realizations should, in principle, lead to consistent results, whereas those based on VPDB-LSVEC should show a bias that increased as samples became more depleted in 13C, with the bias approaching 0.2 ‰ for the most depleted sample. This bias was demonstrated by the participant reporting the most precise measurements based on the VPDB-LSVEC realizations, whereas for 2 participants using VPDB-LSVEC scale realizations other issues dominated the consistency of their results. The 3 laboratories using the NIST (8562,8563, 8564) reference materials (reported as on the VPDB-LSVEC scale), were highly consistent with each other, but the reported bias for the VPDB-LSVEC realization was not evident, with the historical method used for value assignment of the NIST RMs, and their relatively large uncertainty, being identified as possible causes for this. In general, for all results the dispersion was greater than expected based on the measurement uncertainties reported by participants. This dispersion increased as the samples became more depleted in 13C, so that results that were traceable to realizations of the VPDB scale that could be considered equivalent (VPDB and VPDB2020) did not lead to ensembles that were fully consistent within their stated uncertainties. Either the reduced chi-squared or Birge Ratio provide easily calculated quantities to characterise lack of consistency in a data set, where consistent data would lead to values of unity for either of these, and discrepant data leading to increased values. This is most readily demonstrated by considering results based on DI-IRMS with traceability to the VPDB scale through either VPDB and VPDB 2020 realizations, where the standard deviation of 16 results was 0.043 ‰ and a Birge Ratio of 2.7 calculated for nominally −1‰ for δ13C, and the standard deviation was 0.12 ‰ and a Birge Ratio of 2.9 calculated at nominally −9 ‰ for δ18O. For the samples where the nominal δ13C value was −42 ‰, the standard deviation of 17 results was 0.085 ‰ and a Birge Ratio of 4.5 calculated for δ13C, and the standard deviation was 0.24 ‰ and a Birge Ratio of 3.4 calculated for δ18O at nominally −36 ‰. The observed magnitude of the standard deviation of results can also be compared to the standard uncertainty of the IAEA-603 materials certified values (0.01 ‰ for δ13C and 0.04 ‰ δ18O) and the smallest standard uncertainties reported by a participant (0.005 ‰ for δ13C, and 0.01 ‰ for δ18O). These results indicate an underestimation of uncertainty for reported results, especially for those with the smallest uncertainties. Components of uncertainty that should be reviewed before future comparisons include: the uncertainty contribution from reference materials; the uncertainty associated with the phosphoric acid reaction with carbonate reference materials; corrections and uncertainties related to cross-contamination effects in the IRMS; appropriate methods for combining uncertainties of multiple reference materials and accounting for their correlations. A retreatment of results, which normalizes results to the −1 ‰ and −42 ‰ δ13C samples, leads to improvement in the consistency of results as demonstrated for measurements on the nominally −35 ‰ δ13C, −30 ‰ δ18O samples for which the standard deviation is reduced to 0.034 ‰ and 0.057 ‰ for δ13C and δ18O respectively (from 0.072 ‰ and 0.198 ‰ without normalization). The results of the comparison indicate that once issues of non-ideal methods and use of LSVEC are removed, discrepancies in results arise from the challenges in accurately transferring delta values from carbonate reference materials to CO2 gaseous samples, and that these issues can be reduced by having appropriate gaseous reference standards for calibration when measuring CO2 gaseous samples. This is consistent with the identical treatment principle that is preferred in the isotope ratio measurement community. An analysis of results is presented in this report, with further consideration of the impact of the measurement method, the scale, and the reference materials. Uncertainties reported by participants are detailed and analysed, highlighting important differences in the uncertainty sources considered. Although CCQM-P204 was a comparison organised within the CCQM/GAWG and IRWG, no reference value was calculated, mainly because not all results appeared to be strictly on the same scale. Instead, a list of recommendations is provided to encourage more harmonised measurement practices and reach better consistency in future comparisons on similar materials. To reach the main text of this paper, click on Final Report. Note that this text is that which appears in Appendix B of the BIPM key comparison database https://www.bipm.org/kcdb/. The final report has been peer-reviewed and approved for publication by the CCQM, according to the provisions of the CIPM Mutual Recognition Arrangement (CIPM MRA).

7 September 2020 in Metrologia
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
JVJoële Viallon
Joële Viallon
EFEdgar Flores
Edgar Flores
PMPhilippe Moussay
Philippe Moussay
ICIan Chubchenko
Ian Chubchenko
FRFrancesca Rolle
Francesca Rolle
EJE Flores Jardines
E Flores Jardines
The characteristics of an optimized sampling system for measurements of isotope ratios in pure CO 2 gas with Isotope Ratio Infrared Spectroscopy measurement systems that has achieved reproducible measurement of δ 13 C and δ 18 O values with 0.02‰ reproducibility (1 σ) is described. The key elements of the sampling system revolve around almost identical treatment of sample and reference gases allowing two-point calibration of up to 14 samples, and appropriate flushing protocols to remove any biases from memory effects of previously sampled gases. Measurements are performed by the Isotope Ratio Infrared Spectroscopy system at a mole fraction of nominally 700 μmol mol −1 CO 2 in air, by dilution of pure CO 2 gas controlled by individual low-flow mass flow controllers (0.07 ml min −1 ), and with a feedback loop to control mole fractions to ensure that differences between references and sample gas mole fraction stay below 2 μmol mol −1 . This level of control is necessary to prevent biases in measured isotope ratios, the magnitude of which has also been studied with a sensitivity study. The system has been validated using pure CO 2 samples which range in δ 13 C delta values of −1‰ and −45‰ vs VPDB-CO 2 , and in all cases measurement reproducibility over several days of testing of 0.02‰ or better (1 σ) was achieved for both δ 13 C and δ 18 O, with negligible memory effects. The amount of sample gas used for each measurement was less than 5 ml of CO 2 at (RTP), making the system easily deployable for isotope ratio value assignment of bulk CO 2 gas, and adaptable to atmospheric mole fractions of CO 2 in air, and for value assignments of standards. Using the sampling system described the measurement reproducibility of current Isotope Ratio Infrared Spectroscopy systems approaches measurement reproducibility that can be achieved with some IRMS systems.

20 November 2023 in Metrologia
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JVJ Viallon
J Viallon
CMC Meyer
C Meyer
PMP Moussay
P Moussay
JSJ Schmidt
J Schmidt
SMStephen Maxwell
Stephen Maxwell
RWR I Wielgosz
R I Wielgosz
The design, performance characteristics and validation of a next generation reference facility for carbon dioxide (CO2) in air standards based on manometry is presented. Novel attributes of the facility include automated operation, avoidance of significant pressure corrections for measurements on extracted CO2, fully characterized trapping efficiencies, and reduced measurement uncertainty. Improvements in system performance have been achieved using specific materials, notably Silconert®-treated stainless-steel, providing increased mechanical stability whilst minimizing carbon dioxide adsorption on surfaces, and avoiding use of elastomer O-rings, which would lead to losses of CO2. Full automation of the cryogenic extraction process of CO2 from air has been achieved, avoiding any manual intervention within the temperature stabilized section of the facility, and allowed full characterization and correction for trapping efficiencies and trace water measurement. The facility has been validated across the CO2 in air amount fraction range of (380–800) µmol mol−1 using standards with values traceable to the reference value of the CCQM−K120 (2018) comparison. It was demonstrated to operate with a standard measurement uncertainty of 0.09 µmol mol−1 at 400 µmol mol−1. The automation allows five measurement results per day to be produced with a typical standard deviation of the mean at or below 0.02 µmol mol−1. The facility will be used as a stable reference in the future BIPM.QM−K2 ongoing comparison, to compare consistency of amount fraction values in different CO2 in air standards. The CO2 amount fraction in two ensembles of nine BIPM standards covering the same range will also be measured with the facility to provide their SI-traceable values, and further monitored on a longer time scale. Each ensemble will constitute a CO2 in air scale to be compared with other available scales such as WMO.CO2.X2019 through the BIPM.QM−K5 comparison.

23 March 2020
Verified
Conference Paper
Open access
EFEdgar Flores
Edgar Flores
PMPhilippe Moussay
Philippe Moussay
EWEric Mussell Webber
Eric Mussell Webber
ICIan Chubchenko
Ian Chubchenko
Francesca RolleFrancesca Rolle
Francesca Rolle
RWRobert Ian Wielgosz
Robert Ian Wielgosz
This paper will describe the characteristics and performance of a system to prepare up to ten 50 mL samples of pure CO2 with on-demand 13C/12C ratios, together with an optimized calibration system for measurements by Isotope Ratio Infrared Spectroscopy (IRIS) that has allowed measurement of δ13C and δ18O values with 0.02 ‰ reproducibility (1 σ).The needs for improved quality infrastructure and appropriate reference gases for CO2 isotope ratio measurements has been a driver for recent research and development activities within the National Metrology Institutes, and the decision of the Gas Analysis Working Group of the CCQM to plan an international comparison (CCQM-P204) of capabilities of measurements of these quantities. The comparison will be coordinated by the BIPM, which has the mission of preparing the comparison samples, and the IAEA, who will assign their isotopic composition on reference scales. The BIPM has developed a preparation facility based on blending of different pure CO2 sources of very different isotopic compositions, followed by cryogenic trapping and transfer to ten 50 mL cylinders. The target isotopic ratio 13C/12C can be adjusted by accurate flow measurements.A Carousel sampling system with bracketing reference gas calibration and dilution system has been designed at the BIPM to allow rapid and accurate analysis of prepared gas mixtures by IRIS. A key feature of the calibration system is to maintain identical treatment of sample and reference gases allowing two-point calibration of up to 14 samples, and appropriate flushing protocols to remove any biases from memory effects of previously sampled gases. Measurements are performed by the IRIS analyzer at a mole fraction of nominally 700 μmol/mol CO2 in air, by dilution of pure CO2 gas controlled by individual low-flow mass flow controllers (0.07 ml/min), and with a feedback loop to control mole fractions to ensure that differences between references and sample gas mole faction stay below 2 μmol/mol. This level of control is necessary to prevent biases in measured isotope ratios, the magnitude of which has also been studied with a sensitivity study that is also reported.The Carousel and IRIS measurements have been validated using pure CO2 samples prepared with the gas blending facility, covering a range in delta values of -1 ‰ to -45 ‰ vs VPDB, and in all cases measurement reproducibility over several days of testing of 0.02‰ or better (1 σ) were achieved for both δ13C and δ18O, with negligible memory effects.Samples produced and characterized with the facility will be distributed to institutes participting in the CCQM-P204 comparison exrecise, with measurements foreseen in the first quarter of 2020.

1 January 2025 in Metrologia
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JVJoële Viallon
Joële Viallon
FIFaraz Idrees
Faraz Idrees
PMPhilippe Moussay
Philippe Moussay
RWRobert Wielgosz
Robert Wielgosz
WTWilma Travnicek
Wilma Travnicek
PTPeter Trask
Peter Trask
Main text: As part of the ongoing key comparison BIPM.QM-K1, a comparison has been performed between the ozone standard of Germany maintained by the Umweltbundesamt (UBA) and the common reference standard of the key comparison, maintained by the Bureau International des Poids et Mesures (BIPM). The instruments have been compared over a nominal ozone amount fraction range of 0 nmol mol-1 to 500 nmol mol-1. To reach the main text of this paper, click on Final Report. Note that this text is that which appears in Appendix B of the BIPM key comparison database https://www.bipm.org/kcdb/. The final report has been peer-reviewed and approved for publication by the CCQM, according to the provisions of the CIPM Mutual Recognition Arrangement (CIPM MRA).

1 January 2024 in Metrologia
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JVJoële Viallon
Joële Viallon
FIFaraz Idrees
Faraz Idrees
PMPhilippe Moussay
Philippe Moussay
RWRobert Wielgosz
Robert Wielgosz
FKFuuming Kai
Fuuming Kai
JHJoseph Hodges
Joseph Hodges
Main text: As part of the ongoing key comparison BIPM.QM-K1, a comparison has been performed between the ozone national standard of Singapore maintained by the National Metrology Centre, A*STAR (NMC, A*STAR) and the common reference standard of the key comparison, maintained by the Bureau International des Poids et Mesures (BIPM), via a transfer standard maintained by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). The instruments have been compared over a nominal ozone amount-of-substance fraction range of 0 nmol/mol to 500 nmol/mol. To reach the main text of this paper, click on Final Report. Note that this text is that which appears in Appendix B of the BIPM key comparison database https://www.bipm.org/kcdb/. The final report has been peer-reviewed and approved for publication by the CCQM, according to the provisions of the CIPM Mutual Recognition Arrangement (CIPM MRA).