Understanding stakeholder perspectives on forest-water-people relationships is critical for effective environmental governance in tropical landscapes. Yet systematic cross-regional analyses of these perspectives remain scarce. This study employed the Q methodology to investigate diverse viewpoints on forest-water interactions across five pantropical sites including Kenya, Ethiopia, Suriname, Peru, and Ecuador. In addition, participants of four (international) agroforestry workshops/conferences were also interviewed in Brazil, Canada, Indonesia, and Suriname. A structured Q-set of 24 statements representing biophysical, cultural-spiritual, context-dependent, and management-oriented dimensions was administered to 147 participants representing diverse stakeholder groups, including small-scale farmers, Indigenous women, and agroforestry practitioners. Factor analysis revealed four distinct discourses (opinion types): (1) Biophysical conditionality and services, emphasizing mechanistic, context-dependent ecological processes; (2) Spiritual-moral causation and rainfall agency, prioritizing spiritual and moral explanations for hydrological phenomena; (3) Forests as water-securing systems, framing forests as universal providers of water security; and (4) Forest-based buffering, protection, and microclimate services, highlighting forests' protective and regulating functions. Geographic patterns showed strong regional structuring, with mechanistic reasoning dominant in Brazil, Indonesia, and global agroforestry practitioners, spiritual-moral perspectives concentrated in Ethiopia, and water-security narratives prevalent in Ecuador, Kenya, and Suriname. Stakeholder analysis revealed that agroforestry practitioners predominantly held biophysical perspectives on forest-water interactions, Indigenous women emphasized water-security functions, while small-scale farmers exhibited the most heterogeneous viewpoints, integrating spiritual, mechanistic, and experiential knowledge. These findings demonstrate that forest-water governance must accommodate multiple epistemologies and context-specific perspectives to achieve legitimacy and effectiveness in tropical social-ecological systems.