Evidence on the efficacy of impacts from real-world experiments in triggering transformative processes is still scarce. This study evaluates multi-actor labs to provide examples of direct impacts of real-world experiments in tackling long-standing, local, sustainability challenges. Multi-actor labs (MALs), a form of real-world social experiments, were implemented in three coastal-rural regions in France (Charente River Basin), Spain (Mar Menor), and Greece (South-West Messinia) to better assess and tackle coastal-rural interactions that govern local sustainability challenges, such as water use conflicts and biodiversity degradation. The MALs used participative methodologies based on systems thinking and transition management. Stakeholders were continuously engaged in a series of workshops to co-produce knowledge, reach a common understanding of the sustainability challenges and issues at stake, and co-design solutions in the form of a roadmap for sustainable transitions in coastal-rural regions. This paper evaluates MALs to provide examples of successful sustainability transition experiments based on the outputs produced, outcomes achieved, and processes used in the three coastal, rural regions.
9 June 2022 in Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science
Participatory conceptual mapping is widely used in sustainability research to represent stakeholders’ knowledge, concerns, and perceptions of causal relationships within complex social-ecological systems. Yet translating workshop dialogue into reliable, auditable causal maps is labor-intensive and prone to interpretive drift. We present a four-step workflow combining guardrailed large language model (LLM) assistance with human oversight to transform workshop transcripts into DAPSI(W)R(M)-consistent conceptual maps, feedback structures, and qualitative scenarios. The workflow comprises (1) evidence-anchored extraction of nodes and directional links; (2) controlled merging of workshop maps into an identifier-stable representation; (3) identification of vicious cycles, focal points, and virtuous cycles using only the verified combined structure; and (4) scenario tracing through validated pathways. Guardrails include a no-invention rule, quotation-level evidence anchoring, alias tracking, stable identifiers, clean-slate re-entry, and human verification. Applied to two workshops on sustainable fisheries in Catalonia, Spain, the workflow consolidated 64 initial themes and 242 links into 43 themes and 243 verified relations. Three major vicious-cycle systems, several focal points, and twelve virtuous loops and chains informed ten stakeholder-style qualitative scenarios. The case study suggests that guardrailed LLM assistance can support synthesis of stakeholder-derived knowledge while keeping analytical decisions traceable. The workflow provides an auditable foundation for AI-supported participatory systems analysis and identifies future refinements including polarity checks, indicator integration, and empirically testable scenarios.