This study investigates the effects of high current density CO2 electrolysis on the operation of GDE flow cells. It reports a new method of identifying windows of steady-state operation, complementing GDE optimization from a system-perspective.
13 November 2023 in Electrochemical Science Advances
Electrochemical CO2 reduction is a potentially up‐coming technology to convert anthropogenic emitted CO2 into chemical feedstock. Due to alkaline operating conditions of CO2‐electrolyis in gas diffusion electrodes, exothermal hydroxide ion neutralization with the excess of supplied CO2 leads to unavoidable electricity‐to‐heat conversion at the cathode, therefore limiting electrical energy input efficiency. The decomposition reaction of carbonates by protons from water oxidation completes the inherent CO2 transport at the anode. In this work, different production routes to CO are thermodynamically examined and experimentally validated. Using formic acid as an intermediate towards CO the electrical energy input efficiency can rise to 71% on a thermodynamical basis. Additionally, the possibility of altering the mechanism of CO2 reduction under acidic conditions is investigated, which would lead to even larger electrical energy input efficiencies. The concept was investigated by pH series measurements (pH = 0–6) at 50 mA/cm2 where Pb derived from Pb3O4 was used as a CO2 reduction catalyst. The reduction to formic acid under acidic bulk electrolyte pH is stable at FEHCOOH = 70% down to pH 1, while HER is becoming dominant below. Even under such acidic bulk electrolyte conditions no change in reduction mechanism could be forced, which is reflected in invariant cell voltages in the model experiment.
Aiming to advance the technical maturity of CO2 electrolysis to formic acid, various gas diffusion layers (GDLs) are investigated for their suitability as carbon‐based substrate for gas diffusion electrodes (GDEs) and their effect on the electroreduction of CO2 to formate. Particular attention lies on the elucidation for the effect of the GDL thickness, hydrophobic treatment, and presence of a microporous layer (MPL) on the GDE performance in terms of Faradaic efficiency. Based on the investigation it is found that the GDL thickness has no discernible influence on the Faradaic efficiency, while a GDE with a hydrophobic treatment of 10 % PTFE outperforms a GDE based on a GDL with 30 % PTFE. Furthermore, the presence of a MPL is found to be of marked importance to achieve relevant current densities given its effect on the focus of the catalyst layer on the GDE surface after spray coating, the wetting, and the electrical conductivity.
SnO2 nanoparticles have frequently been reported as effective electrocatalysts for CO2 electroreduction to formate. However, in the literature, there is little knowledge of SnO2 nanoparticles that guarantee superior electrocatalytic performance. Hence, in this study, several SnO2 nanoparticles are compared with respect to their material properties, and correlations to the electrocatalytic performance are established. For comparison, three custom-made SnO2-electrocatalysts were prepared, reproducing frequently cited procedures in literature. Based on the comparison, it is found that hydrothermal, sol-gel, and solid-state synthesis provide quite different electrocatalysts, particularly in terms of the particle size and crystal lattice defect structure. Desirably small nanoparticles with a comparatively high number of lattice defects are found for the nanoparticles prepared by hydrothermal synthesis, which also provide the best electrocatalytic performance in terms of Faradaic efficiency for the electroreduction of CO2 to formate. However, despite the considerably smaller surface area, the commercial reference also provides significant electrocatalytic performance, e.g., in terms of the overall produced amount of formate, which suggests a surprisingly high surface area-specific activity for this material that is low on defects. Thus, defects do not appear to be the preferred reaction site for the CO2 electroreduction to formate on SnO2 in this case.
High‐performance gas diffusion electrodes (GDEs) are crucial for large‐scale CO2‐electrolysis. During initial electrode polarization, the startup procedure plays a critical role in determining the subsequent performance of electrodes. This phase influences the course and rate of catalyst formation, as well as electrode‐wetting, and must be carefully managed to prevent initial electrode damage. Maintaining ideal conditions despite added constraints and complexity during scale‐up requires in‐depth understanding of these operational phases. However, progress is limited by the current inability to rapidly analyze product gases. To address this, we present a modified gas chromatography (GC) method capable of sampling every 30 seconds within a limited timeframe, maintaining full data quality. This method was compared and combined with online mass spectrometry (MS), which is faster but comes with calibration challenges and spectral overlaps. We explore the strengths, limitations, and potential synergies of both techniques during electrolyzer startup and for current steps on GDEs with different catalyst layer designs. Experimental results reveal that concentration gradients and additional electrode‐wetting under load primarily occur within the first two minutes. Both fast‐GC and MS methods are effective for product gas analysis within this critical timeframe. We demonstrate the calibration of MS fragmentation signal corrections using simultaneous GC data.
In the eCO 2 R-to-HCOOH with a three-compartment electrolyzer, the choice of a suitable cathodic binder, together with observed catalyst migration and accumulation, may contribute to improving selectivity at higher current densities.