Amid the 2019 coronavirus disease pandemic (COVID-19), the scientific community has a responsibility to provide accessible public health resources within their communities. Wastewater based epidemiology (WBE) has been used to monitor community spread of the pandemic. The goal of this review was to evaluate the need for an environmental justice approach for COVID-19 WBE starting with the state of California in the United States. Methods included a review of the peer-reviewed literature, government-provided data, and news stories. As of June 2021, there were twelve universities, nine public dashboards, and 48 of 384 wastewater treatment plants monitoring wastewater for SARS-CoV-2 within California. The majority of wastewater monitoring in California has been conducted in the urban areas of Coastal and Southern California (34/48), with a lack of monitoring in more rural areas of Central (10/48) and Northern California (4/48). Similar to the access to COVID-19 clinical testing and vaccinations, there is a disparity in access to wastewater testing which can often provide an early warning system to outbreaks. This research demonstrates the need for an environmental justice approach and equity considerations when determining locations for environmental monitoring.
Nature-based solutions, such as green stormwater infrastructure (GSI) have numerous co-benefits alongside stormwater management, including reduced environmental contamination, improved urban aesthetics, and enhanced community health. However, the implementation of GSI often does not benefit marginalized communities and can exacerbate existing inequities through green gentrification. Here, we propose the utilization of a community-based participatory research approach, which highlights procedural equity issues in communities that have historically been excluded from environmental decision-making and benefits through current stormwater management practices. The study outlines the methodological procedure for building strong relationships with communities through partnerships with well-established local non-profit organizations, working to improve the accessibility of research efforts for participants. Through increased accessibility, we gather detailed accounts of community perceptions of GSI among underserved populations in Northeast Houston and Baytown, Texas. Our results show that community members are broadly in favor of implementing GSI and see it as a means to alleviating the effects of environmental degradation. However, there remains distrust of governmental, developmental, and industrial organizations from past experiences during major flooding events. These insights support the need to actively incorporate place-based expertise and insights throughout the process of stormwater management.
Here we report on preliminary efforts to assess the potential to use reclaimed water from municipal wastewater treatment plants for irrigation of vineyards in Napa Valley, California, USA and Valle de Guadalupe, Baja California, Mexico. Vineyards in Napa Valley use a range of source waters including 70 L/s of reclaimed water during the summertime irrigation season. Reclaimed water is secondary effluent that undergoes filtration and disinfection and meets stringent total coliform (<240 MPN/100 mL) and turbidity (10 NTU) requirements. Vineyards in Valle de Guadalupe currently use regional groundwater supplies of marginal quality, and there is interest in expanding source waters to include reclaimed water from nearby Ensenada or the more remote Tijuana. Valle de Guadalupe is drier than Napa Valley and has ongoing salinity management challenges, making the region more sensitive to using reclaimed water for irrigation. Several social and economic factors facilitated the implementation of reclaimed water reuse in Napa Valley for vineyard irrigation, including (1) formation of an assessment district by interested growers to help finance pipeline construction, (2) a long-term reclaimed water vineyard irrigation study by agricultural experts that confirmed the reclaimed water was safe, and (3) a well-defined and relatively low unit cost of reclaimed water. In Valle de Guadalupe, the federal government has approved a project to transport 1000 L/s of reclaimed water over 100 km from Tijuana to Valle de Guadalupe. Questions remain including financing of the project, reclaimed water quality, grower interest in using reclaimed water, and community concerns for such a large-scale program. In considering reclaimed water reuse in vineyards, a key issue is implementation of long-term studies showing that reclaimed water is effectively treated and is safe for irrigation, especially from the standpoint of salt content. In addition, the cost of reclaimed water needs to be comparable with traditional water sources. Finally, in addition to assessing economic constraints, social constraints and water user concerns should be comprehensively addressed in the context of a regional integrated water management framework.