Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to compare the response of two different types of solid‐state microdosimeters, that is, silicon and diamond, and their uncertainties. A study of the conversion of silicon microdosimetric spectra to the diamond equivalent for microdosimeters with different geometry of the sensitive volumes is performed, including the use of different stopping power databases.Method: Diamond and silicon microdosimeters were irradiated under the same conditions, aligned at the same depth in a carbon‐ion beam at the MedAustron ion therapy center. In order to estimate the microdosimetric quantities, the readout electronic linearity was investigated with three different methods, that is, the first being a single linear regression, the second consisting of a double linear regression with a channel transition and last a multiple linear regression by splitting the data into odd and even groups. The uncertainty related to each of these methods was estimated as well. The edge calibration was performed using the intercept with the horizontal axis of the tangent through the inflection point of the Fermi function approximation multi‐channel analyzer spectrum. It was assumed that this point corresponds to the maximum energy difference of particle traversing the sensitive volume (SV) for which the residual range difference in the continuous slowing down approximation is equal to the thickness of the SV of the microdosimeter. Four material conversion methods were explored, the edge method, the density method, the maximum‐deposition energy method and the bin‐by‐bin transformation method. The uncertainties of the microdosimetric quantities resulting from the linearization, the edge calibration and the detectors thickness were also estimated.Results: It was found that the double linear regression had the lowest uncertainty for both microdosimeters. The propagated standard (k = 1) uncertainties on the frequency‐mean lineal energy and the dose‐mean lineal energy values from the marker point, in the spectra, in the plateau were 0.1% and 0.2%, respectively, for the diamond microdosimeter, whilst for the silicon microdosimeter data converted to diamond, the uncertainty was estimated to be 0.1%. In the range corresponding to the 90% of the amplitude of the Bragg Peak at the distal part of the Bragg curve (R90) the uncertainty was found to be 0.1%. The uncertainty propagation from the stopping power tables was estimated to be between 5% and 7% depending on the method. The uncertainty on the and coming from the thickness of the detectors varied between 0.3% and 0.5%.Conclusion: This article demonstrate that the linearity of the readout electronics affects the microdosimetric spectra with a difference in values between the different linearization methods of up to 17.5%. The combined uncertainty was dominated by the uncertainty of stopping power on the edge.
Microdosimetry is increasingly adopted in the characterization of proton and carbon ion beams used in cancer therapy. Spectra and mean values of lineal energy calculated in frequency and dose are seen by many as the tools which, by complementing dosimetric measurements, allow for the most complete characterization of the therapeutic radiation fields. The urgency is now to consolidate the experience and converge to commonly accepted methodologies. In this context, the purpose of this work is to study the effects of the energy-loss straggling and the delta-ray escape, considering slab-sensitive volumes; these are, in fact, the typical shapes of solid-state microdosimeters, which are widely used in investigating light ion therapy beams. The method considers the energy distribution of delta rays resulting from the collision of the impinging ion and, taking into account the escape, convolutes it with itself as many times as the expected number of collisions in the sensitive volume thickness. The resulting distribution is compared to the experimental microdosimetric spectrum showing a substantially good agreement. The extension of the methodology to a wider range of ion energy and detector characteristics is instrumental for a detector-independent microdosimetric assessment of the radiation fields.
4 June 2025 in Zeitschrift für Medizinische Physik
A first benchmark of the Monte Carlo (MC) code GATE was performed for microdosimetry in carbon ion beams. A validated MC model can, in turn, be used to calculate the radiation quality in lineal energy for any number of energies or treatment plans. Measurements were performed at five depths along a carbon ion pencil beam with a nominal energy of 284.7 MeV/u, with additional offside central axis (off-CAX) measurements at four depths. The silicon-on-insulator detector used was modeled with a simplified sensitive volume geometry in the Monte Carlo (MC) toolkit GATE. The source code of GATE was modified to allow the scoring of lineal energy for slab sensitive volumes. On average, the difference between the measured and simulated spectra (assuming the same keVµm-1 cut-off value) was 15 % and 13 % for the frequency-mean and dose-mean lineal energy, respectively. By applying a shift in depth of 500µm towards the beam nozzle, the differences decreased to 10 % and 5 %, mostly affecting the positions in and the fall-off after the Bragg peak. The position in the fragmentation tail showed an edge at a different position than the expected carbon ion edge, which was determined through theoretical (stopping power tables) as well as computational (MC) means to be caused by boron ions. MC is a powerful tool for any potential future clinical application of microdosimetry, provided the beam model has been benchmarked with experimental data. The detector geometry can be approximated with its sensitive volume if the water equivalent thickness of the detector is well known.