Gear Research Center (FZG), Department of Mechanical Engineering, School of Engineering and Design, Technical University of Munich, Garching bei München, Bavaria, Germany
+1
Mr. Felix Farrenkopf
Gear Research Center (FZG), Department of Mechanical Engineering, School of Engineering and Design, Technical University of Munich, Garching bei München, Bavaria, Germany
Low-loss gears are an interesting design approach for increasing the efficiency and thermal load limits of gearboxes. The loss-optimized gear geometry concentrates sliding around the pitch point, which results in low load-dependent gear power losses. In this study, a method for modeling transient EHL (elastohydrodynamically lubricated) contacts in gear mesh considering mixed lubrication and thermal effects is introduced and applied to analyze the tribological behavior of a low-loss gear geometry. Special focus is placed on local frictional losses to analyze the role of the thermal effects of the gear mesh. Although a thermal reduction in fluid friction is observed, the overall effect on total frictional losses of the low-loss gear geometry is evaluated to be very small. The edge geometry strongly influences the lubricant film thickness and frictional power losses.
The reduction of load-dependent gear power loss is one of the key aspects in modern gear design. Therefore, a detailed power loss prediction and the local investigation of its drivers is essential to use its full potential. In this study, the model of the author's previous work is stepwise enhanced to match the real contact conditions as close as possible. The impact of the eliminated simplification or assumption is shown at each of the individual enhancement steps. The proper choice of the lubricant parameters, the coefficient of solid friction and the gear system stiffness show the great impacts on load-dependent gear power losses and the local friction distribution. It is explained how the load-dependent gear power loss of an individual tooth contact is derived from the transient local TEHL contact and subsequently the measurable load-dependent gear power loss of the gear stage. Considering a low-loss gear geometry, the simulation results are compared with experimental results and shows a good level of conformity.
11 August 2025 in Tribologie und Schmierungstechnik
Cylindrical gears are coated with CrAlN+Mo:W:S using High Power Pulsed Magnetron Sputtering and direct current Magnetron Sputtering. Their power loss, bulk temperature, and wear behavior are analyzed on the FZG gear efficiency test rig under dry lubrication. Coated and uncoated gears are examined using laser microscopy, energy-dispersive spectroscopy, and Raman spectroscopy. For operating points with low gear power loss, a tribofilm containing MoS2 as well as Mo and W oxides is detected on the pinion and wheel tooth flank, resulting in a stable tribosystem for several thousands load cycles. Cylindrical gear pairs with CrAlN+Mo:W:S coated wheels exhibit reduced power loss and lower bulk temperatures compared to uncoated gears.
In light of the current efforts to protect the climate and reduce CO 2 emissions, the reduction of load-dependent gear power loss and extension of lifetime are key objectives in gearbox design. In order to achieve this, accurate and detailed prediction models are required. This study employs a mixed TEHL simulation model, which is integrated into an iterative scheme that includes the calculation of gear bulk temperature. The validity of the simulated load-dependent gear power losses was verified for a range of gear geometries and operating conditions. A comparison with mesh- and contact-averaged approaches demonstrates higher accuracy. An exemplarily analysis of the load-dependent gear power loss through local analysis and tooth flank geometry modification shows a potential to reduce the relative load-dependent gear power losses by over 50%. Simulated surface and depth volume material stresses indicate that a tooth flank geometry modification exerts a pronounced effect on the distribution of material stress in lubricated gear contacts. The mixed TEHL simulation approach allows for mesh- and contact-local gear design considering gear power loss and load capacity.