In Poland, bovine tuberculosis (BTB) is most often detected in cattle, although some cases have also been reported in pigs and in other non-domestic species. BTB is believed to be mainly present in the Bieszczady region, in the south-eastern part of the country. The present study analyses the practical applications of the law regarding the eradication of tuberculosis among European bison in Poland, as well as the influence of legal rules in species conservation effects. Its aim is to present and evaluate the effectiveness of legal provisions in selected cases of BTB detected in European bison. The analysis highlights key “critical points” in the management of cases of BTB in European bison, which resulted from the problematic interpretation and application of the existing legal provisions. Findings indicate that before the Animal Health Law, the eradication of BTB in European bison in Poland was not regulated clearly enough by the applicable laws in force prior to 2021. This posed a threat to an effective reintroduction strategy for bison based on creating larger metapopulations and maintaining small, isolated reservoir herds (breading centers) for fallback in the case of infectious disease. It should be emphasized that in the current legal system, there is no doubt that a District Veterinary Officer has the competence to prevent and control tuberculosis in European bison.
Law of animal humane protection as comprehensive branch of administrative law The legal protection of animals may be discussed on the grounds of branches of law such as civil law, criminal law or administrative law. Due to the essence of the protected “interest”, in this case animals, their protection in the most comprehensive way was provided by the norms of administrative law. The additional systematization of this form of protection is inscribed in the aforementioned administrative law. For this reason, it is possible to discuss e.g. regulations on the humane protection of animals, environmental protection of animals or protection of animal health. Such parts of administrative law can be referred to as its comprehensive sections. At present, however, such a classification raises uncertainties – therefore, a division into comprehensive sections of administrative law was suggested. In the structure of such a section, to ensure better security of the protected interest, in addition to the typical norms of administrative regulations, there are norms from other branches of law, like civil law or administrative law.
WHY A NEW ACT ON THE HUMANITARIAN PROTECTION OF ANIMALS IS NEEDED?Legal regulations concerning animals protection clearly state that man owes to respect the animal and each animal requires humane treatment that must be understood by taking into account the needs and protection of animals, as far as care providing. Systematic law amendments, which are concerned to protect the animals from suffering, including unjustified or inhumane killing or cruelty to animals, should be considered as the duty of state authorities. In particular it should be done due to taking into account that animals are recognized as the “subjects of law”, for which there is a special legal regime determined by the provisions devoted to the humanitarian animals protection.The main objective of this article is to identify the aspects, which — according to the author — affect the need to make amendments to the existing provisions concerning humanitarian protection of animals. This includes lack of law transparency, containing its precision and often contradictory regulations. Also, adapting to European regulations should be considered as important issue. Failure in application of European rules to national law means that the Republic of Poland violates its obligation as the Member State of the European Union. The author also notes that the current range of the requested changes proposed by law doctrine, state authorities, as well as by social organizations whose statutory purpose is humanitarian protection of animals is so broad, concerns so conflicting values and interests, as well as some of them are so “revolutionary”, that it requires a comprehensive and systemic look at the humanitarian issue of animal protection at the national level. Hence, instead of performing complicated amendments creation of avery new act on the humanitarian protection of animals should be considered.
30 August 2024 in Przegląd Prawa Administracyjnego
In the context of growing global awareness regarding animal protection and requirements for their treatment, administrative oversight of animal welfare is gaining importance as a key element in ensuring the proper functioning of the state and its institutions in enforcing administrative law norms. The article focuses on defining and discussing the objectives of administrative oversight in the context of animal welfare, highlighting its multidimensional nature, which serves not only to protect animal rights but also to maintain overall welfare standards. Through a review of existing positions in doctrine and jurisprudence, the author aims to define administrative oversight of animal welfare in the material aspect, considering preventive and reactive actions and the main goal, which is to improve living conditions for animals. In light of this perspective, he argues that effectively conducted administrative oversight can contribute to faster and more efficient improvement of living conditions for animals than traditional criminal proceedings. The considerations have both dogmatic and practical significance, emphasizing the role that administrative oversight can play in improving animal welfare. Highlighting the effectiveness of administrative tools in protecting animal rights contributes to the discussion on the superiority of these tools over penal legal measures, offering new perspectives on achieving better living standards for animals.