Cast-in-place (CIP) reinforced concrete (RC) box culverts are the most common type of culvert in the United States. As buried structures, the structural behavior of CIP RC box culverts under earth loads and vehicular live loads is not fully understood, and accurate load rating remains challenging. Relevant communities have conducted research and developed codes to achieve more realistic load ratings. This paper provides a comprehensive review of current guidelines, practices, and state-of-the-art research on load rating CIP RC box culverts. The review encompasses national standards, state procedures, standard plans, and publications from agencies and institutes. Additionally, commonly used structural analysis and rating software for culverts is introduced. The paper identifies and discusses key parameters and assumptions that affect load rating, and examines various analysis techniques, including 2-D analysis, 3-D analysis, and soil-structure interaction modeling. Using single-cell and multicell culvert examples, this paper conducts a study to quantify the influence of identified key parameters and analysis techniques, validating results from existing literature. The conclusion summarizes the findings, offers suggestions for load rating practices, and identifies areas requiring further investigation in future research.
The utilization of intermediate diaphragms (IDs) in precast concrete (PC) I-girder bridges has been a topic of debate among researchers for decades, with its effectiveness remaining a subject of controversy. Nevertheless, the consideration of IDs is an essential aspect of engineering practice, making it crucial to explore their role in live load moment distribution. This study delves into the application of concrete IDs, examining the impact of various finite element modeling practices and key parameters on their effectiveness. A sensitivity study was conducted to compare the efficacy of grillage, planar, and solid models in determining the suitable modeling approach for straight, skewed, and curved deck bridges equipped with IDs. To optimize modeling practices, a further investigation was undertaken to evaluate the influence of different parameters on the role of IDs, including the presence of IDs, the rigidity of connections between IDs and girders, and several geometric parameters related to the bridge span layout. The live load moment envelope of girders was chosen as the response indicator to evaluate the role of IDs. The findings of the parametric study revealed that the removal of IDs leads to an increase in the midspan moment of the interior girders, while the midspan moment of the exterior girders decreases. Furthermore, it was found that the rigidity of connections between IDs and girders, girder spacing, and span length significantly influence the role of IDs in PC I-girder bridges.
Many cast-in-place reinforced concrete box culverts in Louisiana were built using outdated standard plans originated from the 1940s and updated in the 1970s. These culverts often yield low load rating factors when evaluated using current AASHTO procedures. Despite this, they performed satisfactorily overtime with minimal signs of distress. Simple 2D frame element models are commonly used for structural analysis of typical box culverts due to their ease and speed. However, they tend to produce more conservative load rating results compared to complex modeling techniques like 3D plate element models. A parametric study was conducted using 120 3D finite element culvert models in various configurations, along with corresponding 2D frame element models. Correction factors were developed to correlate moment values from 3D and 2D analyses. Field testing of representative culverts was also performed to validate the analytical models. The study considered two types of wall-slab connections: pinned and moment connections. The results indicate that using moment connections, an at-rest lateral earth pressure coefficient, ko of 0.50, and the 3D-2D correction factor, yields more realistic load rating values that reflect field conditions. The study’s findings were used to develop guidelines for load rating reinforced concrete box culverts in Louisiana, which can also be applied to similar culverts elsewhere.
This study investigates the structural behavior of steel I-beams containing corrosion-induced section loss and web openings, along with the effectiveness of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) strengthening as a retrofit strategy. Although previous studies have investigated the effects of corrosion, web openings, and FRP strengthening in steel beams, limited attention has been given to comparing the structural response of slender and deep steel beams under these deterioration scenarios and assessing strengthening strategies according to their distinct failure mechanisms. The analysis considers two structural response regimes: slender beams governed predominantly by flexural behavior and deep beams where shear deformation plays a significant role. Three-dimensional (3D) nonlinear solid finite element (FE) models are developed to evaluate the influence of corrosion location, web opening position, and FRP-strengthening schemes on load-carrying capacity and failure behavior. The results indicate that corrosion-induced flange thinning significantly reduces flexural capacity in slender beams, while web degradation has a comparatively smaller effect. FRP strengthening of the tension flange is found to be the most effective strategy for restoring flexural performance in slender beam configurations. In contrast, deep beams exhibit higher sensitivity to shear-related damage, where web openings located in shear transfer regions lead to substantial reductions in load capacity. Strengthening of the web region using FRP significantly improves shear resistance and overall structural performance. Overall, the study highlights distinct differences in damage sensitivity and strengthening effectiveness between slender and deep beam responses under corrosion and web opening effects, providing practical guidance for condition assessment and retrofit design of deteriorated steel I-beams.