Nonstructural elements (NEs) are generally defined as elements typically housed within buildings/facilities that are not part of the structural system. Nonstructural elements are often classified as architectural elements, mechanical/electrical/hydraulic systems, and building contents. Nonstructural elements are often associated with critical seismic risk, due to their high vulnerability and exposure to seismic actions, especially for critical facilities such as hospitals and nuclear plant facilities. Accordingly, the combination of major exposure and vulnerability makes NEs extremely critical in terms of seismic risk even for low to moderate seismicity. The paper reviews and evaluates the main international testing approaches and protocols for the seismic assessment of NEs by means of experimental methods, which are referred to for seismic qualification. Existing test protocols are technically analyzed considering quasi-static, single-floor dynamic, and multi-floor dynamic procedures, supplying technical and operative guidance for their implementation, according to the latest advances in the field. The study proposes novel perspectives and a unified approach for the seismic assessment and qualification of NEs. The technical recommendations lay the groundwork for a more robust and standardized testing and qualification framework. In particular, the provided data might represent the first step for developing code and regulation criteria for the experimental seismic assessment and qualification of NEs.
4 January 2024 in Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics
The paper investigates the seismic response of nonstructural elements (NEs), focusing on acceleration‐sensitive components housed in buildings, modelled as inelastic Ibarra–Medina–Krawinkler (SDOF) systems. Incremental dynamic analysis (IDA) is carried out considering (a) representative suites of building floor motions (real loading histories recorded within reinforced concrete (RC) buildings and table testing protocol inputs) and (b) a wide range of NE models (with elastic frequencies ranging within 1–9 Hz). The Ibarra‐Medina‐Krawinkler (IMK) model was implemented in OpenSees, defining the key modeling parameters according to the formulations provided by Lignos and Krawinkler. Both IDA curves and component (acceleration) amplification factor (CAF) are characterized, also considering statistical measures. The seismic capacity of the investigated NEs is estimated through fragility curves, accounting for five incremental damage states (DSs). The fragility parameters are correlated with the frequency of the NE models, and (statistical‐based) closed‐form capacity criteria are provided. The study provides a robust technical and scientific methodological framework for assessing the seismic capacity of NEs that can be modeled by inelastic SDOF systems. The findings have a potential major impact on both research and practice, enriching scientific knowledge and providing useful applicative tools. In particular, quantitative response and capacity measures are supplied, and the developed capacity criteria can be particularly useful for expeditious but reliable design and assessment, as well as for comparison purposes.
The seismic response of freestanding elements is typically extremely critical, and this is associated with a high seismic risk in the case of museum objects and artefacts. This paper reports the preliminary results of an experimental testing campaign aimed at assessing the dynamic properties and the seismic performance of museum objects and artefacts. Shake table tests of a typical museum display case containing a representative art object (vase) are performed. Both dynamic properties and seismic behavior of the specimens were assessed. Tentative damage assessment correlations are developed. The study sheds light on the critical behavior of the tested specimens, stressing the need for further studies towards a more comprehensive assessment of freestanding museum objects and artefacts.
10 January 2021 in Fatigue & Fracture of Engineering Materials & Structures
The paper investigates both local and global capacity criteria for collapse assessment of RC frame buildings. Both literature and regulations criteria are considered, also including the formulation recommended in the draft of the new Eurocode 8 (part 3) and other collapse criteria never investigated. The case studies consist of low-rise bare and infilled frame buildings, which are designed according to the Italian code provisions considering low-to-high seismicity sites in Italy. The seismic demand is estimated by performing multiple-stripe analysis based on inelastic modeling, also including the presence of the infills. The capacity assessment and the performance evaluation associated with the (building) collapse are carried out according to the latest approaches and methodologies of performance-based earthquake engineering. The investigated capacity criteria are characterized as a result of the collapse assessment in terms of (a) collapse demand to capacity ratios, (b) collapse fragility curves, (c) collapse margin ratios and probabilities, and (d) inter-capacity margin ratios. The findings provide novel information and technical insights into the influence of the collapse capacity criteria selection on the collapse features of the investigated buildings. In particular, the capacity criteria are quantitatively correlated to the building collapse performance, also outlining safety and economic considerations.