Present results provided new information on the practice of removing iron from waterlogged wood using chelating agents. Two series of samples were selected: small waterlogged wood samples of Quercus spp., Pinus sylvestris L. and Pinus pinaster Aiton, and a portion from the dismantled shipwreck Huguangjiao I. Iron extractions were carried out using disodium ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) and diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid (DTPA). Samples were characterized by environmental scanning electron microscopy coupled with dispersive energy spectrometry, micro-Raman spectroscopy, atomic absorption spectroscopy, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA), the latter used to evaluate viscoelastic properties. The extraction efficiency of both products was good, although it depended on the wood state of preservation, being higher in more decayed material. Still, the extraction procedures induced a limited effect on the decayed wood tissue, affecting both cell wall chemical composition and physical characteristics. Moreover, a significant difference existed between the two agents. In decayed hardwoods, they had an impact on both E’ (decrease) and tanδ (increase), mostly apparent for DTPA. The difference between DTPA and EDTA was also more evident when the frequency was varied in DMA tests. In contrast, the well-preserved softwood was not affected by the considered treatments.
Treatments of organic objects to extract ferrous compounds from waterlogged archaeological wood are well documented. For several years, numerous laboratories have been seeking to determine suitable conservation treatments for such organic objects. For chemical treatments, complexing agents such as EDTA and DTPA, along with acids such as citric and oxalic acids, were selected. In addition, oxidants and reducing agents were tested as pre-treatments to improve extraction rates. In fact, chemicals produce a selective reaction on ferrous compounds, which may improve or be inhibited by complexation or dissolution reactions. Their action depends on the type of compound to be extracted and those present inside the wood. The objective of this study was to make a comparative assessment of the various chemical conservation treatments identified and complement the evaluation of their extraction efficiency with a study of their impact on organic matter by adding criteria such as their visual aspect (using a spectrocolorimeter) and physicochemical actions by means of infrared spectroscopy and micromorphological observations. The effectiveness of EDTA was confirmed, as was that of citric acid, despite some questions arising concerning the presence of wood fibers in the treatment solution, even after rinsing. On the other hand, the extraction rate of oxalic acid, which has a very acidic pH, was unsurprisingly lower, but its visual and anatomical results raised the possibility of using it over a short period of time in view of the effectiveness observed on the wood surface. Pre-treatments improved extraction rates, except in the case of EDTA, which independently had a high extraction rate. It was observed that pre-treatments did not appear to cause any significant chemical degradation of the organic matter. This study provides a tool to assist conservators in selecting a chemical treatment that is in line with the state of decay of the wood, the characteristics of the ferrous compounds to be extracted, and the conservation objectives.
The Iulia Felix is a 2nd-century AD Roman shipwreck that was discovered off the coast of Grado in 1986. Following its recovery, the hull was dismantled and treated with high concentrations of PEG 4000 at elevated temperatures. This process was completed in 2003. The elements were then stored for over 20 years. During this prolonged storage period, salt efflorescence developed on some surfaces, raising concerns about ongoing degradation and prompting an investigation into the composition of the wood and how environmental conditions influence it. The efflorescence was analysed using scanning electron microscopy with energy dispersive spectroscopy (SEM-EDS), X-ray powder diffraction (XRPD) and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR). To evaluate the impact of environmental factors, samples were exposed to controlled humidity levels of 35% and 85% until equilibrium was achieved. The analyses identified iron- and sulphur-based compounds, including hydrated ferrous sulphates, calcium sulphate and hydrated iron oxides. These findings suggest a corrosion-related degradation process that originates in a marine burial environment and progresses in humid, oxygen-rich conditions after recovery. The presence of PEG within the efflorescence indicates that environmental conditions after treatment promoted its gradual migration to the surface. Climate testing revealed that PEG 4000 significantly reduced hygroscopic exchange with the environment. Under dry conditions, dimensional changes were minimal, with less than 1% variation in mass and surface area. In contrast, prolonged exposure to high humidity resulted in a 11% increase in mass due to moisture uptake, as well as a roughly 5% increase in surface area. This was accompanied by minor cracking and, in some cases, structural failure. This study highlights the long-term conservation challenges posed by waterlogged archaeological wood treated with high-molecular-weight PEG. It emphasises the importance of continuous environmental monitoring to mitigate degradation processes and preserve structural integrity, providing valuable insights for future museum conservation strategies.
The Iulia Felix is a 2nd century AD Roman wreck discovered on the seabed off Grado in 1986. After being recovered, the hull was dismantled and its components were treated with PEG 4000 at high concentrations and temperatures. The treatment and drying pro-cess were completed in 2003. While awaiting exhibition, the wreck elements were stored in a stockroom, where they were preserved for over 20 years. However, this prolonged storage has introduced new variables. In particular, salt efflorescence has appeared on the surfac-es of some elements, raising concerns about potential further degradation. This made in-vestigating this efflorescence and studying how environmental conditions may affect the state of the treated wood particularly pertinent. The efflorescence was analysed using mi-croanalysis performed with a scanning electron microscope equipped with an energy dis-persive spectroscopy probe (EDS), X-ray powder diffraction (XRPD), and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy. To verify the effect of climate on the treated material, some samples were exposed to severe but realistic humidity levels of 35% and 85% for an ex-tended period until equilibrium was reached. Analysis of the efflorescence revealed the presence of iron- and sulphur-based com-pounds, namely hydrated ferrous sulphates, calcium sulphate and hydrated iron oxides. This indicates that the ship’s elements had been affected by a corrosion process typically associated with the degradation of metal components. This process begins in a maritime environment and is completed in a humid, oxidative environment following artefact re-covery. Moreover, the presence of PEG in the efflorescence indicates that the artefact un-derwent unforeseen conditions after treatment that caused PEG to migrate to the surface over time. Environmental tests showed that using PEG 4000 for treatment significantly slowed down hygrometric exchange with the environment. However, exposure to a dry climate resulted in limited deformation due to minimal mass change (less than 1% for both mass and surface area), whereas prolonged exposure to a humid environment caused an 11% mass increase (due to water vapour absorption), resulting in a ca. 5% increase in sur-face area. This phenomenon was accompanied by the onset of minor cracks. In some cases, however, the samples fractured. Overall, this work contributes to the ongoing under-standing of the preservation challenges faced by underwater archaeological finds, partic-ularly with regard to treatment with high molecular weight PEG. It highlights the need for continuous monitoring to address degradation and its impact on the structural integrity of the wrecks, and provides a basis for future conservation strategies in museums.