Background/Objectives: The stability of dual mobility (DM) total hip arthroplasty (THA) is often attributed to reduced impingement incidence and a superior range of motion (ROM) compared to the corresponding values when standard implants are used. However, few studies have directly explored this. Thus, the purpose of the present study was to compare the incidence of impingement and the range of motion between standard and DM acetabular cups, whose diameters are suited to the same patient anatomy. Methods: One standard and two DM implants were virtually implanted into a pelvis using a previously developed geometric model. Joint motions, which were representative of seven dislocation-prone activities of daily living (ADLs), as well as walking, were applied to each device type at a range of cup orientations (inclination/anteversion). Conclusions: There were no placement positions that avoided impingement across all seven ADLs, regardless of cup construct type. A similar impingement incidence and ROM were observed for standard and DM constructs, although the consequences of impingement are potentially more serious for DM devices (metal–metal contact) than for standard constructs (metal–polyethylene contact). This finding contradicts the common notion that DM-THAs have a reduced impingement incidence and superior ROM, instead suggesting that their stability may be attributed to alternative mechanisms, such as increased jump distance.
Dual mobility (DM) implants are being increasingly used for total hip arthroplasties due to the additional range of motion and joint stability they afford over more traditional implant types. Currently, there are no reported methods for monitoring their motions under realistic operating conditions while in vitro and, therefore, it is challenging to predict how they will function under clinically relevant conditions and what failure modes may exist. This study reports the development, calibration, and validation of a novel inertial tracking system that directly mounts to the mobile liner of DM implants. The tracker was custom built and based on a miniaturized, off-the-shelf inertial measurement unit (IMU) and employed a gradient-decent sensor fusion algorithm for amalgamating nine degree-of-freedom IMU readings into three-axis orientation estimates. Additionally, a novel approach to magnetic interference mitigation using a fixed solenoid and magnetic field simulation was evaluated. The system produced orientation measurements to within 1.0° of the true value under ideal conditions and 3.9° with a negligible drift while in vitro, submerged in lubricant, and without a line of sight.
24 May 2023 in Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H: Journal of Engineering in Medicine
Despite their emerging use, the current understanding of the in-vivo functional mechanisms of Dual Mobility (DM) Total Hip Replacements (THRs) is poor, and current characterisation methodologies are not suitable for the unique function and design of these types of devices. Therefore, the aim of this study was to develop a geometric characterisation methodology to estimate dimensional change across the articulating surfaces of retrieved DM polyethylene liners so that their invivo function may be better understood. The method involves the acquisition of three-dimensional coordinate data from the internal and external surfaces of DM liners. The data is processed using a bespoke MATLAB script which approximates the unworn reference geometry of each surface, calculates geometric variance at each point and produces surface deviation heatmaps so that areas of wear and/or deformation may be visualised across the implant. One as-manufactured and five retrieved DM liners were assessed, which demonstrated the efficacy, repeatability and sensitivity of the developed method. This study describes an automated and non-destructive approach for assessing retrieved DM liners of any size and from any manufacturer, which may be used in future research to improve our understanding of their in-vivo function and failure mechanisms.
Background/Objectives: Asymmetric acetabular liners used in Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) are clinically successful in reducing revision associated with dislocation. The performance of an asymmetric liner is dependent on its positioning, although few studies have directly investigated the effects of variables such as cup orientation or extended rim position on outcomes such as impingement. Therefore, the aim of this study was to compare the incidence of impingement in THA with a standard and lipped liner. Methods: A THA was virtually implanted into a previously developed geometric model. Acetabular cups were placed in a range of clinically relevant orientations, and the model was moved through seven joint motions associated with dislocation-prone Activities of Daily Living (ADLs). The occurrence of implant–implant, implant–bone, and bone–bone impingement was assessed for the standard and lipped constructs across a total of 6,237 unique combinations of cup orientation and lipped liner apex rotations. Results/Conclusions: The model predicted that with both standard and lipped constructs, there were no component placement positions which avoided impingement for all ADLs. The number of impingement incidents was minimised when components were positioned at the higher end of the manufacturer’s recommendations for cup inclination and anteversion. The use of a lipped liner increased the frequency of impingement events compared with the standard construct. However, for anterior impingement leading to posterior dislocation, this increase may be minimised by rotating the lip apex to a posterior-inferior position. Anterior lip apex placement tended to minimise the increase in the less critical posterior impingement.
Despite their emerging use, the in vivo behaviour of dual-mobility (DM) total hip replacements (THRs) is not well understood. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to assess the articulating surfaces of 20 early-retrieved DM polyethylene liners (mean length of implantation 20.0 ± 18.8 months) for damage to improve the current understanding of their in vivo functional mechanisms. The internal and external surfaces of each liner were visually and geometrically assessed, and the material composition of embedded debris particles were further characterized. Scratching and pitting were the most common modes of damage identified on either surface, and a high incidence of burnishing (50%) and embedded debris (65%) were observed on the internal and external surfaces, respectively. Embedded debris particles were commonly titanium- or iron-based, although other materials such as cobalt-chrome and tantalum were also identified. The geometric assessment demonstrated highly variable damage patterns across the liners, with the internal surfaces commonly presenting with crescent-shaped, circumferential, or circular regions of penetration whilst the external surfaces commonly presented with regions of deep pitting or gouging. This study demonstrates that DM-THRs primarily articulate at the head/liner junction, and that polyethylene liners are capable of rotating about the femoral neck axis, although the extent of this may be limited in some cases. Additionally, this study suggests that intra-prosthetic dislocation and edge loading may remain pertinent failure mechanisms of DM implants despite the advent of highly crosslinked polyethylene and design features, thus highlighting the need for enhanced monitoring of these devices.