A sensors network based on 11 nodes (10 stationary and 1 mobile mounted on public bus) distributed in Bari (Italy) has been deployed for urban air quality (AQ) monitoring. The low-cost sensor-systems have been installed in specific sites (buildings, offices, schools, streets, port, airport) to enhance environmental awareness of the citizens and to supplement the expensive official air monitoring stations with cost-effective sensor-nodes at high spatial and temporal resolution. Continuous measurements were performed by low-cost electrochemical gas sensors (CO, NO2, O3, SO2), optical particle counter (PM1.0, PM2.5, PM10), NDIR infrared sensor (CO2), photo-ionisation detector (total VOCs), including microsensors for temperature and relative humidity. The sensors are running to assess the performance during a campaign (June 2015–December 2017) of several months for citizen science in sustainable smart cities. The air quality index (AQI) for a given pollutant has been measured and compared to the public reference environmental data. The results of the AQ monitoring long-term campaign for selected sensor-nodes are presented.
In recent years, the availability on the market of low-cost sensors (LCSs) and low-cost monitors (LCMs) for air quality monitoring has attracted the interest of scientists, communities, and professionals. Although the scientific community has raised concerns about their data quality, they are still considered a possible alternative to regulatory monitoring stations due to their cheapness, compactness, and lack of maintenance costs. Several studies have performed independent evaluations to investigate their performance, but a comparison of the results is difficult due to the different test conditions and metrics adopted. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) tried to provide a tool for assessing the possible uses of LCSs or LCMs by publishing guidelines to assign suitable application areas for each of them on the basis of the mean normalized bias (MNB) and coefficient of variance (CV) indicators. Until today, very few studies have analyzed LCS performance by referring to the EPA guidelines. This research aimed to understand the performance and the possible application areas of two PM sensor models (PMS5003 and SPS30) on the basis of the EPA guidelines. We computed the R2, RMSE, MAE, MNB, CV, and other performance indicators and found that the coefficient of determination (R2) ranged from 0.55 to 0.61, while the root mean squared error (RMSE) ranged from 11.02 µg/m3 to 12.09 µg/m3. Moreover, the application of a correction factor to include the humidity effect produced an improvement in the performance of the PMS5003 sensor models. We also found that, based on the MNB and CV values, the EPA guidelines assigned the SPS30 sensors to the “informal information about the presence of the pollutant” application area (Tier I), while PMS5003 sensors were assigned to the “supplemental monitoring of regulatory networks” area (Tier III). Although the usefulness of the EPA guidelines is acknowledged, it appears that improvements are necessary to increase their effectiveness.
The air quality in modern cities and urban areas is strongly affected by chemical pollutants such as toxic gases, volatile organic compounds, and particulate matter. They are monitored by governmental agencies using regulatory monitoring stations, which are highly accurate, but also very expensive, bulky, and maintenance demanding. There is a compulsory need to monitor air quality at high spatial–temporal resolution in smart cities for public health protection and environmental sustainability. Properly calibrated low-cost and low-accuracy sensors are usually deployed in stationary and mobile nodes for urban air quality monitoring. A simple indicator of the current status of urban air pollution is the Air Quality Index (AQI) used to communicate the pollution level under the time-changing trend of a specific pollutant. In this study, continuous measurements have been performed in the city of Bari (southern Italy) by electrochemical gas sensors (NO2, O3, CO), optical particle counters (OPC) for particulate matter (PM10), and NDIR infrared sensors (CO2), including microsensors for temperature and relative humidity. The sensors have been installed in stationary nodes located in urban sites and in a mobile node mounted on a public bus moving on urban routes. AQI data gathered by the low-cost sensors have been compared with reference instrumentations as a case study of citizen science.
A sensor network based on 10 stationary nodes distributed in Bari (Southern Italy) has been deployed for urban air quality (AQ) monitoring. The low-cost sensor systems have been installed in specific sites (e.g., buildings, offices, schools, streets, ports, and airports) to enhance environmental awareness of the citizens and to supplement the expensive official air-monitoring stations with cost-effective sensor nodes at high spatial and temporal resolution. Continuous measurements were performed by low-cost electrochemical gas sensors (CO, NO2, O3), optical particle counter (PM10), and NDIR infrared sensor (CO2), including micro-sensors for temperature and relative humidity. The sensors are operated to assess the performance during a campaign (July 2015–December 2017) of several months for citizen science in sustainable smart cities. Typical values of CO2, measured by distributed nodes, varied from 312 to 494 ppm (2016), and from 371 to 527 ppm (2017), depending on seasonal micro-climate change and site-specific conditions. The results of the AQ-monitoring long-term campaign for selected sensor nodes are presented with a relative error of 26.2% (PM10), 21.7% (O3), 25.5% (NO2), and 79.4% (CO). These interesting results suggest a partial compliance, excluding CO, with Data Quality Objectives (DQO) by the European Air Quality Directive (2008/50/EC) for Indicative (Informative) Measurements.
This work presents the “City Dynamics and Smart Environment” activities of the Smart Ring project, a model for the smart city, based on the integration of sustainable urban transport services and environmental monitoring over a 4–5-km circular path, the “Smart Ring”, around the historical center of l’Aquila (Italy). We describe our pilot experience performed during an experimental on-demand public service electric bus, “SmartBus”, which was equipped with a multi-parametric air quality low-cost gas electrochemical sensor platform, “NASUS IV”. For five days (28–29 August 2014 and 1–3 September 2014), the sensor platform was installed inside the SmartBus and measured air quality gas compounds (nitrogen dioxide, carbon oxide, sulfur dioxide, hydrogen sulfide) during the service. Data were collected and analyzed on the bases of an air quality index, which provided qualitative insights on the air status potentially experienced by the users. The results obtained are in agreement with the synoptic meteorological conditions, the urban background air quality reference measurements and the potential traffic flow variations. Furthermore, they indicated that the air quality status was influenced by the gas component NO , followed by H S, SO and CO. We discuss the features of our campaign, and we highlight the potential, limitations and key factors to consider for future project designs.
A sensors network based on 8 stationary nodes distributed in Bari (Southern Italy) has been deployed for urban air quality monitoring during advection events of Saharan dust in the period 2015–2017. The low-cost sensor-systems have been installed in specific sites (buildings, offices, schools, streets, airport) to assess the PM10 concentration at high spatial and temporal resolution in order to supplement the expensive official air monitoring stations for citizen science purposes. Continuous measurements were performed by a cost-effective optical particle counter (PM10), including temperature and relative humidity sensors. They are operated to assess the performance during a long-term campaign (July 2015–December 2017) of 30 months for smart cities applications. The sensor data quality has been evaluated by comparison to the reference data of the 9 Air Quality Monitoring Stations (AQMS), managed by local environmental agency (ARPA-Puglia) in the Bari city.