This paper presents the concept of complementary measurements with the use of two methods that allow for a more detailed assessment of the mechanical condition of a transformer's active part. These methods are frequency-response analysis (FRA) and vibroacoustic method (VM). The VM was interpreted separately in steady and transient conditions, thus allowing, together with the FRA measurements, the determination of possible source of vibrations. This paper presents a theoretical introduction, experimental measurements performed on a real transformer with introduced controlled deformations and, finally, an example of a practical application.
3 November 2015 in IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery
This paper presents verification of frequency-response analysis (FRA) and vibroacoustic-method (VM) test methods complementarity for the assessment of the mechanical condition of a transformer's active part. Experiments performed on real power transformers under field conditions are discussed. The presented results cover three cases of faults which would be difficult to detect or correctly interpret with the application of a single method only. The first case shows the interfering influence of radiators on VM results. In the second case, a loosened winding with unchanged geometry, which cannot be detected by the FRA method, is discussed. The third presented case shows the results of an experiment based on introducing faults into the active part followed by FRA and VM tests. These faults were loosening of the core and loosening of winding with its slight stretching. The first fault could only be detected, as expected by VM results analysis, while the second one was confirmed by both methods; however, FRA assessment quality depends on the method of test data comparison.
Frequency Response Analysis (FRA) is an important tool used for diagnostic measurements of power transformers. Standard test configuration applied in the industry is the end-to-end open test setup; however, an interwinding capacitive configuration is also used. This paper presents a method—Cross Test Comparison (CTC)—for simultaneous analysis of results coming from both the mentioned test setups. Such an approach could offer a more sensitive tool for detecting some faults; moreover, it takes into consideration the influence of both voltage sides of a transformer in a one test result. The authors have used several indices to quantitatively assess the test results and proposed new approach to data interpretation. CTC method was tested using data from measurements performed in three cases: a unit tested in laboratory with introduced controlled deformations; transformers measured under industrial conditions; and a transformer with FRA changes resulting from tap-changer operations. The results showed that CTC method is more effective at detecting faults on the basis of FRA measurements.
The paper provides a review of the modelling techniques used to simulate the frequency response of transformer windings. The aim of the research and development of modelling methods was to analyze the influence of deformations and faults in the windings on the changes in the frequency response. All described methods are given with examples of the modelling results performed by the authors of this paper and from literature sources. The research is prefaced with a thorough literature review. There are described models based on lumped parameters with input data coming from direct calculations based on the winding geometry and obtained from FEM modelling software and models considering the wave phenomena in the windings. The analysis was also performed for practical problems in winding modelling: the influence of windings other than the modelled one and the influence of parallel wires in a winding.
Frequency Response Analysis (FRA) is a test method used for assessment of mechanical condition of transformer active parts. Its biggest problem is the interpretation of test results, namely the relationship between scale of differences between compared curves and the decision for further operation of the given transformer. Very often visible differences between two FRA curves do not mean that there is a deformation in the winding. The cause of the curve shift may come from other elements of the transformer that influence inductive or capacitive parameters. This paper takes under consideration the influence of both capacitance and inductance changes on transformer frequency response (FR). The analysis is performed with the computer model of a transformer and also some experimental results are presented, showing the influence of capacitance and inductance changes on the FR of real transformers. The results of research showed that this influence may lead to misleading effects on the shape of FR characteristics. The paper presents an analysis that can be used in the assessment of FRA measurement, especially in the case of uncertain data comparison results.
Frequency response analysis (FRA) is a popular method for assessing a transformer’s mechanical condition. The paper proposes a new method for interpreting the frequency response measurement results. The currently used numerical indices only give one value, which may be misleading in the analysis, while the proposed frequency response quality index (FRQI) tool analyses three separate features in the whole frequency range. The applied numerical calculations technique allows for estimations of not only the values of the average quality indices, but also locally for given frequency ranges of the analysed spectrum. It allows for determination of the problems that can be found in the active part of a transformer. The presented results come from three transformers, representing cases of typical faults. Two of them are from industry, while one was used for deformational tests in laboratory conditions. The proposed FRQI method showed its usefulness in FRA test results analysis and may be introduced into the automated assessment of such data. Each of the component parameters is sensitive to other types of differences observed between the compared frequency response curves, and may be used as a good quality detection tool.