Resumo Este artigo, inserido no campo de estudos acerca do fenômeno da letalidade prisional no Brasil, tem como objetivo examinar a construção jurídica das identidades indígenas de pelo menos cinco pessoas que morreram em um massacre ocorrido no Complexo Penitenciário Anísio Jobim (Compaj), situado na cidade de Manaus, estado do Amazonas, nos dois primeiros dias do ano de 2017. Amparado por diferentes campos empíricos, este estudo mobiliza, principalmente, a análise documental de uma ação civil pública promovida pelo Ministério Público Federal (MPF), que busca responsabilizar o estado do Amazonas e a empresa cogestora da unidade prisional à época, a fim de observar a jurisdicionalização da responsabilidade estatal pela lente da identidade.
Deaths caused by or connected to exposure to Brazilian prisons are widely acknowledged as frequent and preventable, yet official data fails to capture their scale, causes, and circumstances. To circumvent what official administrative datasets miss, this article examines an original dataset of 1077 criminal case files from 27 Brazilian state courts involving individuals who died between 2017 and 2021 after having been incarcerated. Drawing on the systematic document review of these cases, we analyze sociodemographic characteristics, health information, causes of death, and judicial responses, distinguishing between deaths occurring in custody (“internal”) and after release (“external”). Our findings reveal pervasive omissions in basic demographic and medical information, extensive use of ill-defined causes of death, and a striking absence of investigation in most cases, including deaths under direct state custody. We identify instances of obfuscation and judicial inaction that, together with the absence of reliable administrative data, are likely to sustain institutional ignorance and normalize preventable deaths. This study advances debates on incarceration and health, state accountability, and proposes the concept of prison lethality: the capacity of carceral spaces to increase people’s exposure to health risks and harms, combined with the epistemic practices that shed light on or obfuscate this capacity.
24 March 2021 in Revista Brasileira de Direito Processual Penal
Este artigo, utilizando como método a observação participante e a análise documental de provimentos e documentos judiciais relacionados à execução da pena em meio aberto no estado de São Paulo, tem como propósito elaborar descrições e reflexões sobre o regime aberto e da prática do comparecimento periódico em juízo. Partindo da contextualização acerca dos regimes de invisibilização do cumprimento de pena em regime aberto identificados na pesquisa, o artigo apresenta alguns aspectos da organização judiciária da execução da pena em São Paulo e em seguida descreve cenas e elementos do comparecimento periódico em juízo em dois setores diferentes do fórum criminal da Barra Funda, o maior fórum criminal da América Latina, localizado na cidade de São Paulo.
The “Carandiru Massacre” was a police operation in a prison (São Paulo, Brazil) that resulted in at least 111 deaths of individuals deprived of their liberty and countless victims of physical and psychological injuries. The delay in holding public agents (military police officers) accountable, the absence of any charges against political agents (the governor and the secretary of security), along with the endless legal proceedings for victim reparations and the complete erasure of this territory with the deactivation of the house of detention and the subsequent construction of a park ( Parque da Juventude ) on the site, reflect the multiple layers of rights violations faced by people under state custody in Brazil and their families. This article aims to highlight the ambiguity of the law’s role in the realm of state violence, observing legal norms and decisions as both producers of violence and mechanisms for recognition, accountability, and reparation. In doing so, it explores ways to describe state violence through the lens of law, without being constrained by legal categories. The proposed reconfiguration draws on a broad documentary archive and multiple interactions with survivors and the territory to analyze the Carandiru Massacre and its implications from the perspective of person, institution, and space.