To enable precise manipulation of fragile objects, robots need the sense of touch. Localized sensing of the 3D force vector with a few mN of resolution is desired. Magnetic force sensors, consisting of a magnet embedded in an elastomer and a 3D magnetometer, were demonstrated as desirable candidates. These prior-art sensors measure the local 3D magnetic field at a single sensing pixel. Hence, they cannot distinguish between the signal and stray magnetic fields. Any stray field directly leaks into the force readout signal path. This letter introduces a design immune to stray magnetic fields. The sensor uses multiple magnetic pixels, and operates on the gradient of the magnetic field. The pixels and conditioning electronics are fully integrated on chip. The 3D force calculation is based on a polynomial model fitted to a calibration data set. The impact of a 2-mT magnetic stray field on the force output is limited to 0.3% of the full scale—about two orders magnitude improvement over the prior art. The force resolution is 2.7 mN and remains competitive. Furthermore, an on-chip temperature sensor and an algorithm are used to compensate the intrinsic thermal drift in the range 0–50 ${}^{\circ }$ C. To validate the proper force regulation in spite of a nearby magnet, we integrated our prototype into a robotic hand. Our results demonstrate the robustness of 3D magnetic force sensors in the presence of real-world parasitic disturbances.
This survey paper compiles and benchmarks the performance of integrated magnetic sensors, in terms of their noise and full-scale magnetic field. In total, we collected performance metrics of 31 sensors realized in various technologies. For each sensor, we derived a noise model to estimate the noise under the same conditions. We obtained a comprehensive benchmark with a focus on integrated devices. We also measured the noise spectrum of 11 of those sensors to confirm our noise model. Given that for many emerging applications, such as tactile, current, torque and biomagnetic sensing, the signal of interest is the field gradient to reject magnetic stray fields, we extended the benchmark to gradiometers. We developed a low-noise measurement setup and a low-field gradient (full scale: 10 μT/mm) generation setup to characterize magnetic gradiometers in this regime. The paper discusses the key sensor trade-off between precision and range, and summarizes the technology trends graphically on a trade-off curve, providing broad insight.
We present a new Hall sensor design for the accurate and robust measurement of linear displacement. Implemented in CMOS, the sensor is based on a novel gradient measurement concept combining Hall elements with integrated magnetic concentrators. In typical applications with practical Ferrite magnets, the peak output voltage of the Hall transducers is only around 1.7 mV at the maximum operating temperature of 160℃, and thus requires high-performance low-offset readout electronics. Over its 15-mm linear displacement range, the sensor’s total error is 1% including manufacturing tolerances, trimming accuracy, temperature, aging effects, and practical magnet constraints. In addition, the sensor is immune to magnetic stray fields up to 5 mT, complying with the most stringent automotive norm.
Magnetic and inductive sensors are the dominant technologies in angular position sensing for automotive applications. This paper introduces a new angular sensor: a hybrid concept combining the magnetic Hall and inductive principles. A magnetic Hall transducer provides an accurate angle from 0° to 180°, whereas an inductive transducer provides a coarse angle from 0° to 360°. For this novel concept, a hybrid target with a magnetic and inductive signature is also needed. Using the two principles at the same time enables superior performances, in terms of range, compactness and robustness, that are not possible when used separately. We realized and characterized a prototype. The prototype achieves a 360° range, has a high accuracy and is robust against mechanical misalignments, stray fields and stray metals. The measurement results demonstrate that the two sensing principles are completely independent, thereby opening the doors for hybrid optimum magnetic–inductive designs beyond the usual trade-offs (range vs. resolution, size vs. robustness to misalignment).
The manipulation of delicate objects remains a key challenge in the development of industrial robotic grippers. Magnetic force sensing solutions, which provide the required sense of touch, have been demonstrated in previous work. The sensors feature a magnet embedded within a deformable elastomer, which is mounted on top of a magnetometer chip. A key drawback of these sensors lies in the manufacturing process, which relies on the manual assembly of the magnet–elastomer transducer, impacting both the repeatability of measurements across sensors and the potential for a cost-effective solution through mass-manufacturing. In this paper, a magnetic force sensor solution is presented with an optimized manufacturing process that will facilitate mass production. The elastomer–magnet transducer was fabricated using injection molding, and the assembly of the transducer unit, on top of the magnetometer chip, was achieved using semiconductor manufacturing techniques. The sensor enables robust differential 3D force sensing within a compact footprint (5 mm × 4.4 mm × 4.6 mm). The measurement repeatability of these sensors was characterized over multiple samples and 300,000 loading cycles. This paper also showcases how the 3D high-speed sensing capabilities of these sensors can enable slip detection in industrial grippers.
Contactless magnetic position sensors are used in countless industrial and automotive applications. However, as a consequence of the electrification trend the sensors can be exposed to parasitic magnetic stray fields, and their desired robustness may be compromised. In this paper we publish for the first time how this challenge is addressed and constructively solved using a complete paradigm change leaving conventional magnetic field measurement behind and entering into the realm of magnetic field gradient measurement. Our novel sensor system consists of an integrated Hall sensor realized in 0.18 μm CMOS technology with magnetic concentrators and a four-pole permanent magnet. The intrinsic angular accuracy was assessed comparing the rotary position of the permanent magnet with the sensor output showing angle errors below 0.3°. Additional end-of-line calibration can be applied using built-in memory and processing capability to further increase the accuracy. Finally, we demonstrate the immunity against stray fields of 4000 A/m which led to errors below 0.1°, corresponding to 0.06% of the sensors fullscale angular range. In conclusion, this novel sensor system offers a compact and flexible solution for stray-field immune rotary position measurement in harsh environment.