For many years, objectivity was considered a key norm of quality in audio description (AD), and it still features prominently in many AD guidelines. The primary motivation behind the concept is a recognition of users' autonomy in forming a mental image of the audiovisual content independently. Research has offered many alternative views on the issue that conceptualise the idea of objectivity/subjectivity as a continuum, emphasizing that different approaches can be appropriate depending on the given context of situation, giving rise to different AD styles that cater for a range of aesthetic preferences. Against this background, various cultural domains are experimenting with alternative approaches, challenging established AD practices and the assumptions it is built on. The articles included in this special issue all explore the various ways in which AD user needs can be met and illustrate the dynamic views that exist on objectivity, addressing key questions related to the operationalisation of objectivity, the challenge of interpretation for AD, the exploration of emerging subjective styles, and the concept of aesthetics of or in access.
18 March 2020 in International Journal of Applied Linguistics
This paper summarises the contributions to EuroCALL’s CorpusCALL SIG Symposium for the year 2020. In line with this year’s EuroCALL conference theme, ‘CALL for widening participation’, the Symposium centred around the theme of Data-driven learning for languages other than English. This paper gives a brief overview of developments and challenges when using Data-Driven Learning (DDL) to teach French, German, Italian, and Spanish. As research suggests, a DDL approach has been effectively utilised to teach these languages. However, there are differences in available DDL resources and corpora for the respective languages that are appropriate for language teaching. The main challenges for future developments are also discussed.
The benefits of direct corpus exploration by language learners are widely attested for tertiary education contexts but less so for secondary school environments. The integration of data-driven learning (DDL) into a teacher education program is a promising method to spread the word, although there may still be barriers that hinder trainee teachers from viewing direct corpus exploration as a viable option for the secondary language learning classroom. Which sorts of barriers can be identified? To what extent are they linked to technical issues or to conceptual ones? This chapter attempts to answer these questions by exploring how a module on technology-enhanced course design was used to introduce selected features of Sketch Engine to trainee teachers of L2 German in a French secondary school context, training them in basic corpus exploration methods with a view to creating a corpus-based language learning task for use for younger learners. The results suggest both technical (“first order”) barriers (e.g. limited knowledge of corpus query syntax, complex corpus functions) and conceptual (“second order”) barriers (e.g. teacher beliefs about younger learners’ capabilities, preferences for other teaching tools) hinder both trainees’ DDL task construction and their eventual uptake of corpus use with younger learners. These issues could be resolved by providing the trainees with corpus query samples together with reusable and adaptable corpus-based activities, as well as user-friendly corpus tools and pedagogically relevant resources.
Johns reports in his text “Kibbitzing one-to-ones” (1997) that corpus-informed metatalk with a foreign language expert helps apprentice writers to make progress in independent text revision. Expecting this progress to be based on the development of expert-like ways to observe language features, I integrated Johns’ so-called kibbitzing methodology into a German course based on the TV love story Weissensee. The course, offered to a group of French students, included online discussions focused on verb particles considered to be relevant for execution of the writing task, which was to invent a film script scene for the Weissensee series. The students used the specialised Weissensee corpus and the general corpus deTenTen as writing aids. Both were accessed through the Sketch Engine concordancer. This article outlines the way in which the students talked with their teacher about language samples retrieved in concordance lines or in the first drafts of their writing tasks. Qualitative and quantitative analysis of the data – the scripts of the discussions and the transcript of the filmed interview – provides the following results: the students got more insight into the semantic complexity of verb particles, and they got a better understanding of the link between content and form.
In this paper, we present a foreign language learning approach inviting the learner to reflect on the linguistic system. We define "the reflecting learner" as a thinking being who decides to engage in thinking rather than following the teacher's invitation to reflect on his or her performed action. After describing our references (the theory of enunciative operations, the conceptualisation approach, etc.), we give an overview of the main questions which must be answered when designing a learning scenario including language reflection activities. These questions are related, for instance, to the choice of learning objectives and materials and to the choice of metalinguistic terms. The last part of the article presents and analyzes the main characteristics of two recent scenarios, in order to show how a reflective approach can be implemented. In these scenarios, the use of technologies, in particular of an online forum or of online corpora, plays a positive role.