The aim has been to determine the effect of thermo-mechanical cycling on shear-bond-strength (SBS) of dental porcelain to Co-Cr and Ti-based alloys fabricated by casting, computer-numerical-controlled milling, and selective-laser-melting (SLM). Seven groups (n=22/group) of metal cylinders were fabricated by casting (Co-Cr and commercially pure-cpTi), milling (Co-Cr, cpTi, Ti-6Al-4V) or by SLM (Co-Cr and Ti-6Al-4V) and abraded with airborne-particles. The average surface roughness (Ra) was determined for each group. Dental porcelain was applied and each metal-ceramic combination was divided into two subgroups - stored in deionized water (24-h, 37°C), or subjected to both thermal (6000-cycles, between 5 and 60°C) and mechanical cycling (105-cycles, 60N-load). SBS test-values and failure modes were recorded. Metal-ceramic interfaces were analyzed with a focused-ion-beam/scanning-electron-microscope (FIB/SEM) and energy-dispersive-spectroscopy (EDS). The elastic properties of the respective metal and ceramic materials were evaluated by instrumented-indentation-testing. The oxide thickness on intact Ti-based substrates was measured with Auger-electron-spectroscopy (AES). Data were analyzed using ANOVA, Tukey's HSD and t-tests (α=0.05). The SBS-means differed according to the metal-ceramic combination (p<0.0005) and to the fatigue conditions (p<0.0005). The failure modes and interface analyses suggest better porcelain adherence to Co-Cr than to Ti-based alloys. Values of Ra were dependent on the metal substrate (p<0.0005). Ti-based substrates were not covered with thick oxide layers following digital fabrication. Ti-based alloys are more susceptible than Co-Cr to reduction of porcelain bond strength following thermo-mechanical cycling. The porcelain bond strength to Ti-based alloys is affected by the applied metal processing technology.
1 March 2020 in The Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry
The heat treatment of dental alloys prior to porcelain application/veneering has been proposed as a way to ensure sufficient oxide scale and to promote the porcelain’s adherence in porcelain-fused-to-metal (PFM) fixed dental prostheses. The present study investigates the relationship between the bond strength of the dental porcelain to selective-laser-melted (SLM) titanium and the temperature of the titanium’s pre-oxidation. The SLM Ti-6Al-4V substrates were airborne-particle abraded and either left to passivate in air at room temperature (control) or pre-oxidized in a furnace under vacuum conditions (10 kPa) at temperatures of 300, 600, 750, or 800 °C. The surface characteristics were determined using contact profilometry to measure the profile roughness (Ra), atomic force microscopy for the surface roughness (Sa) and Auger electron spectroscopy for the thickness of the oxide scale. Dental porcelain was applied to the metal substrates and the titanium-ceramic bond was assessed according to the ISO standard 9693-1:2012. The metal-ceramic interfaces were analyzed with scanning electron microscopy and energy-dispersive spectroscopy. The Ra and Sa values showed a strong positive correlation with the pre-oxidation temperature. The oxide scales covering the titanium surfaces thickened markedly at temperatures of 750 °C and above. However, the bond strength was negatively correlated with the pre-oxidation temperature. Room-temperature passivation in air following the airborne-particle abrasion of the SLM titanium resulted in a titanium-ceramic bond that is well above the ISO 9693-1:2012 recommended minimum value for metal-ceramic systems. Thus, no pre-oxidation of SLM titanium frameworks is necessary prior to the application/firing of porcelain.