Predictive control (PC) has been extensively studied in power electronics, particularly for inverters and rectifiers, with growing attention to DC–DC converters, including interleaved, multilevel, and resonant topologies for single-port and multiport applications. However, comprehensive studies on classical DC–DC converters (buck, boost, buck-boost, and noninverting buck-boost) remain scarce. This article presents a systematic review and experimental benchmarking of the four most relevant PC strategies: finite control set model PC (FCS-MPC), hysteresis-based PC (HB-PC), continuous control set MPC (CCS-MPC), and dead-beat control, enabling a practically comparable experimental evaluation using the most relevant performance metrics. All strategies are implemented on the same rapid-control-prototyping platform and evaluated based on steady-state error (SSE), inductor current ripple (ICR), and computational cost (CC). Experimental results reveal clear performance tradeoffs. CCS-MPC offers the most balanced performance across all metrics and topologies, with an average SSE of 122 mA, an ICR of 0.90 A, and a CC of 27%. Dead-beat control achieves the lowest ICR (0.69 A) and CC (19.5%) but exhibits the highest SSE (184 mA). HB-PC delivers the lowest SSE in buck and boost converters (35 mA to 155 mA), although at the expense of increased ICR and CC (exceeding 43%). FCS-MPC offers flexibility in constraint handling but imposes the highest computational burden (48% average CC) without outperforming the others in SSE or ICR. The comparative analysis demonstrates that no single strategy excels across all metrics; instead, the optimal choice depends on application-specific priorities, such as accuracy and numerous research articles. For practicing engineers, this article provides practical guidelines for selecting and implementing PC in classical DC–DC converters.