1 October 2021 in Marine Pollution Bulletin
Several risk management frameworks have been introduced in the literature for maritime Pollution Preparedness and Response (PPR). However, in light of the actual needs of the competent authorities, there is still a lack of framework that is established on a sound risk conceptual basis, addresses the different risk management decision-making contexts of organizations, and provides tools for various risk management questions of this field. To alleviate the limits of existing approaches, this paper introduces a new risk management framework for this purpose, which was developed in cooperation with the competent authorities and other maritime experts. The framework adopts the risk-informed decision-making strategy and includes three aligned components. The first component provides a unified theoretical risk concept to the framework through an interpretation of the Society for Risk Analysis risk approach. The second consists of four ISO 31000:2018 standard based processes focused on different risk management decision-making contexts of the PPR organizations. The third comprises a set of practical risk assessment tools to generate the needed information. A case study provides an example of the functionality of this framework with integrated data from the northern Baltic Sea. To conclude, a risk concept is provided for the PPR authorities and their stakeholders as well as processes for managing the risk and tools for its assessment.
3 January 2024 in WMU Journal of Maritime Affairs
Maritime authorities have the administrative responsibility for the safety and security of shipping and the prevention of marine and atmospheric pollution caused by ships. This responsibility involves various tasks that can be supported through effective risk management, but currently, there are no models available to evaluate its level of maturity in maritime administrations. To fill this gap and respond to the needs identified by maritime authorities, this article introduces a new risk maturity model called the R-Mare matrix. This model is built on recent scientific knowledge in the field of risk management, and it has been designed in close cooperation with end-users and maritime risk management experts using the Delphi methodology. As a result of this process, the article provides a qualitative risk maturity matrix specifically tailored to support the self-evaluation of maritime authorities. The matrix consists of 17 state-of-the-art risk management attributes, a five-step risk maturity scale, and associated risk maturity grid descriptions. These elements can be used to evaluate the current risk management performance of maritime authorities, identify areas for improvement, and develop a plan to achieve a higher level of maturity. Overall, the R-Mare matrix model represents an important step forward in this field while laying the foundation for further development.
13 October 2025 in WMU Journal of Maritime Affairs
The R-Mare matrix is the first risk maturity model developed for maritime authorities. Its main purpose is to support the authorities in self-evaluating their current risk management performance and in steering that performance toward higher levels. To gain insight into the model’s usability in practical applications, the aim of this study is to test the reliability of its measurements in real-world settings and identify areas for improvement. The empirical testing is conducted within maritime administration in the Baltic Sea region and involves two rounds of semi-structured interviews with 16 panelists. During these interviews, the panelists employ the R-Mare matrix model to provide individual ratings of their administration’s risk management performance and justify their expert judgments. To achieve a comprehensive understanding of the model’s reliability, the collected data is analyzed using internal consistency reliability and inter-rater reliability tests. For the former, statistical quantifications are performed using Cronbach’s Alpha and McDonald’s Omega coefficients, while for the latter, the Intraclass Correlation Coefficient is employed. These tests are conducted separately for the results of both interview rounds to further address the model’s temporal stability. The findings indicate a high degree of internal consistency reliability, and at least a moderate degree of inter-rater reliability for the model’s measurements. These further highlight areas for improvement in the model and assist in developing strategies to enhance its reliability. Consequently, the results provide evidence of the reliability of the R-Mare matrix model’s measurements, while supporting its deployment in the maritime administrations of the Baltic Sea region and beyond.