Despite being frequently proposed as a low-carbon solution for wastewater treatment and solar fuel production, the feasibility of photocatalytic processes in large-scale deployments remains unclear. This review evaluates the scalability of photocatalytic technologies by synthesizing a decade (2015–2025) of techno-economic analysis (TEA) and life-cycle assessment (LCA) studies. Using a systematic search and programmatic screening, 77 assessment-focused publications were identified from an initial corpus of 854 studies. Across applications, TEA and LCA consistently highlight two dominant barriers to scale-up: high electricity demand in UV-driven systems and significant cradle-to-gate impacts associated with catalyst synthesis, particularly for nanostructured materials. When solar irradiation replaces artificial light, environmental and economic hotspots shift from energy use to material production, catalyst durability, and reuse assumptions. Wide variability in reported costs and impacts reflects heterogeneous methodologies, limited pilot-scale data, and a lack of standardized reporting. Overall, assessment-based evidence indicates that photocatalysis is not yet ready for widespread industrial deployment as a large industrial process. However, continuous advances in solar-driven reactor design, low-impact and circular catalyst synthesis, hybrid process integration, and harmonized TEA/LCA frameworks could substantially improve its prospects for scalable, climate-positive implementation, especially in the context of emerging green energy alternatives.
16 March 2021 in Environmental Science and Pollution Research
BioLPG is a partially renewable fuel that can be produced by different conversion routes, with vegetable oil hydrotreatment (HVO) being one of the most promising processes. This study uses the Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) approach to assess the environmental impacts associated with this processing. The analysis considered the conditions practiced in Brazil with soybean oil (SO) as raw material, different hydrogen sources, and raw materials’ feed rates in the reaction system. The model was based on secondary data collected for the 2020–2021 biennium, and the environmental impacts were determined for Global Warming Potential, Primary Energy Demand, Terrestrial Acidification, Fine Particulate Matter Formation, Terrestrial Ecotoxicity, and direct Land Use Change. The results show that the SO produced by soybeans grown in Paraná/BR and hydrotreated with H2 obtained by electrolysis ([SO/H2]mol/mol = 1:30) had the best environmental performance in four of the six impact categories analyzed. A complementary analysis also identified the best environmental performances for bioLPG obtained from blending SO from different sources to avoid supplier dependence. Even accumulating worse environmental performance than fossil LPG, renewable fuel has promising prospects for deployment in Brazil. Nevertheless, for this to occur, some actions must be implemented in its production cycle.
Orange-juice production represents a significant, world-leading economic sector in Brazil. Orange processing residues, however, correspond to 50% to 60% of the in natura fruit mass. Despite the high amount of generated waste, which is disposed of in landfills or used as raw material to produce low-value animal feed, studies on the use of this waste are still developing in Brazil. However, orange peels contain compounds that can be precursors to higher value-added products in different sectors. Therefore, this study presents a conceptual proposal for a biorefinery integrated into the orange-juice-production route to assess integrated processes’ technical, environmental, and economic performance to convert waste into chemicals, fuels, and energy. A stationary process simulation model was developed to analyze the manufacturing of four products, namely, D-limonene, pectin, biomethane, and electricity, comparing the results to the conventional feed production route according to generated revenue and environmental impacts. The results indicate that pectin production is the highest financial-return route, presenting the most significant environmental impact, whereas D-limonene production is more attractive, generating the second-highest revenue with the lowest associated environmental impacts.
Despite the importance of inputs such as urea, ethanol, and acetic acid for the global production of food, energy, and chemical bases, manufacturing these substances depends on non-renewable resources, generating significant environmental impacts. One alternative to reducing these effects is to integrate production processes. This study compares the cumulative environmental performance of individual production routes for ethanol, urea, and acetic acid with that of an integrated complex designed based on Industrial Ecology precepts. Life Cycle Assessment was used as a metric for the impact categories of Global Warming Potential (GWP) and Primary Energy Demand (PED). The comparison occurred between the reference scenario, which considers individual processes, and six alternative integrated arrangements that vary in the treatment given to a stream concentrated in fuels generated in the Carbon Capture and Usage system that serves the processing of acetic acid. The study showed that process integration is recommended in terms of PED, whose contributions were reduced by 46–63% compared to stand-alone processes. The impacts of GWP are associated with treating the fuel stream. If it is treated as a co-product and environmental loads are allocated in terms of energy content, gains of up to 44% can be expected. On the other hand, if the stream is a waste, the complex’s GWP becomes more aggressive than the baseline scenario by 66%.