This study evaluated the degree of conversion (DC), polymerization kinetics, and temperature of a new self-cure bulk-fill resin-based composite (Stela Automix, SDI). The study was divided into seven groups: (1) Stela Primer, (2) Stela Automix, (3) Stela Automix exposed to light for 20 s after 100 s, (4) Stela Primer with Stela Automix, (5) Stela Primer with Stela Automix and exposed to light for 20 s after 100 s, (6) Scotchbond Universal with Stela Automix, and (7) Scotchbond Universal with Stela Automix and exposed to light for 20 s after 100 s. The real-time reaction rates and DC at the bottom of 2 mm thick specimens at ∼32 °C were measured at 720 s after insertion using a spectrometer with an Attenuated Total Reflectance detector. The temperature of Stela, Stela exposed to light, Stela Primer with Stela, and Stela Primer with Stela exposed to light were measured by an infrared thermal camera in human molar teeth with Class I cavities. The temperature was recorded in real-time every 0.03 s for 720 s. The results were compared with ANOVA and Tukey's multiple comparison test (α = 0.05). The highest degree of conversion (DC) at the 2 mm depth was achieved when Stela Primer was combined with Stela (72.4 ± 3.5 % at 720 s). Stela could self-cure independently, but not as rapidly or effectively as when used with its Primer. The greatest temperature increase was for the light-cured Stela, followed by Stela Primer with Stela RBC exposed to light for 20 s. The Scotchbond Universal bonding system did not significantly increase the DC compared to Stela alone, except when exposed to light for 20 s, which slightly increased the final DC. Exposing Stela to light for 20 s did not improve the final DC of Stela as much as using the Stela Primer, but it did increase the temperature and prolonged the time taken to return to 37 °C. The Stela primer accelerates the degree of conversion of Stela. The reaction occurred rapidly and achieved a higher DC at the bottom of the specimens where the Stela was in contact with the Stela primer. Exposing Stela to light for 20 s is not recommended. Instead, Stela should be used with Stela Primer.
To examine the effects of the resin-based composite (RBC) thickness and incident irradiance on the time delay after the light turns on before polymerization starts at the bottom surface of the RBC. The degree of conversion (DC) was determined using Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR) at a rate of 13 measurements per second. Six commercial RBCs were tested at three thicknesses (0.2, 2 and 4 mm) and four incident irradiance values (472-3985 mW/cm2). There was a significant time delay before polymerization began at the bottom of each RBC. At 942 mW/cm2, representative of many current LCUs, this delay ranged from 0.12 to 1.11 s at the bottom of 2 mm of RBC. When the thickness was increased to 4 mm, even with an irradiance of 1969 mW/cm2, which represents high-power LCUs, the delay ranged from 0.12 to 5.17 s. The highest irradiance of 3985 mW/cm2 did not fully overcome the inherent lag caused by the thickness of the RBC. At 3985 mW/cm2, PowerFlow and PowerFill had the shortest delay times of 0.09 s and 0.30 s, respectively, at the bottom of a 4 mm thick RBC. The presence of a time delay before photo-cured RBCs start to polymerize at the bottom surfaces must now be addressed clinically and when calculating reaction rates.
To determine the presence of exposure reciprocity in nine resin-based composites (RBCs) using fast (3 s, high irradiance) or standard light-curing modes for 10 s, 20 s, or 30 s. Five sculptable and four flowable bulk-fill RBCs were light-cured using a Bluephase PowerCure light-curing unit (LCU). The RBCs were divided into groups according to the exposure modes tested: fast (3 s mode - at 3130 mW/cm2), or for the manufacturer's recommended time on the standard (High mode at 1226 mW/cm2). The degree of conversion (DC) and reaction rates were measured at 0.2 mm and 4 mm depths for 720 s using real-time spectroscopy. Light transmission (%) was also recorded (n = 3). Parametric or non-parametric 2-way ANOVA was used depending on the data (α=0.05). When compared to the values from the bottom of their 0.2 mm thick value, except for TPFlow-3 s and TPlusFlow-3 s, the bottom of the 4-mm thick specimens had a significantly different DC. Only TPF and TPFlow were statistically the same for both modes at 4 mm; ABF-3 s and OBF-3 s had the lowest DC at the bottom of 4 mm. OBF-3 s had the highest reaction rate at 0.2 mm (61.6 ± 1.2 %/s) while FOBF-10 s had the slowest rate (3.1 ± 0.1 %/s) at the bottom of 4 mm. OBF, BRFlow, TPFlow, TplusFill and TplusFlow had different light transmission patterns than the other RBCs. Depending on the brand of RBC, there was a measurable delay of 0.1 to 2.9 s at the bottom of the RBCs before the polymerization reaction started. Exposure reciprocity does not exist for all RBCs. Depending on the brand of RBC at the bottom of 4 mm there was a measurable delay of 0.1 to 2.9 s before polymerization started. Exposure reciprocity depends on the RBC. Short exposures (3 s) using higher irradiance should only be used when recommended by the manufacturer of the RBC.
1) To investigate two empirical models used to characterize the polymerization kinetics of six resin-based composites (RBCs) and 2) the impact of the sampling rate on the time-varying degree of conversion (DC). The DC of three sculptable and three flowable RBCs was recorded using attenuated total internal reflectance Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy at a collection rate of 13 DC/s. A multiple-diode light-curing unit delivered either an irradiance of 1.2 or 3 W/cm2. The RBC specimens were either 0.2 mm or 4 mm thick and were photocured at 32 ºC. Sampling rates as low as 0.2 DC/s were simulated by numerically interpolating the measured DC(t). The DC(t) obtained at different sampling rates was fitted to the dual-exponential and autocatalytic models. For all six RBCs, the fit of the autocatalytic model to the data resulted in the smallest mean squared errors. The lower simulated sampling rates did not represent the highly time-resolved DC collected at an irradiance of 3 W/cm2 and specimen thickness of 0.2 mm. For the DC simulated at a sampling rate of 0.2 DC/s using PowerFill and analyzed with the autocatalytic model, the maximum DC rate was 3.7 %/s, occurring at a time of 5 s after the start of photocuring. However, using a sampling rate of 13 DC/s, they were 64.5 %/s and 116 ms, respectively. The autocatalytic model was found to better characterize the kinetics of RBC photopolymerization than the dual-exponential model. The data collection rate has a strong influence on the results.
This study measured the beam divergence angle and light output from dental light curing units (LCUs). Twenty LCUs were assessed using a laboratory-grade wide beam imager to determine the relationship between the beam divergence on the irradiance as a function of distance from the light tip. The irradiance (mW/cm2) and beam divergence angles (°) at 5, and 10 mm from the tips of 18 Light-Emitting Diode (LEDs), 1 Quartz-Tungsten-Halogen (QTH), and 1 Laser diode LCU. There were significant differences in the power, irradiance, and emission spectra from the 20 LCUs. At 10 mm from the LCU tip, the irradiance delivered by one LCU decreased by approximately 85.7 %, whereas this decrease was as low as 5.6 % for a different LCU. There was a positive correlation between the divergence angle reported by the wide beam imager and the reduction in irradiance. The laser diode LCU had the least beam divergence and the smallest decrease in irradiance as the distance increased. In contrast, the QTH LCU with the turbo light guide had the greatest beam divergence and the greatest reduction in irradiance as the distance increased. 50 % of the LCUs tested would require exposure times longer than 20 s to deliver 10 J/cm2 at the 10 mm distance. The wide beam imager is a useful tool for measuring the beam divergence from LCUs and predicting the effect of distance on their irradiance. At 10 mm, some LCUs may require a fivefold increase in the exposure time to deliver the same energy they deliver at 0 mm from the tip of the LCU.
The polymerization shrinkage stress (SS), degree of conversion (DC), and Vickers hardness (HV) are properties that can affect the performance of resin-based composites (RBCs). This study tested four bulk-fill RBCs used in self-cured mode: Bulk EZ Plus (Zest Dental Solutions), Cention Forte (Ivoclar), Fill-Up! (Coltene), and Stela (SDI Limited), and two light-cured bulk-fill RBCs: Filtek One (Solventum) and SDR flow+ (Dentsply). The test specimens were 6 mm in diameter and 2 mm thick. Axial SS was measured in real time for 4000 s in the self-cured materials and for 1400 s after 10 s of light curing in the light-cured materials (n = 12 for self-cured RBCs; n = 11 for light-cured RBCs). To confirm that the RBCs were adequately polymerized, the DC was assessed using real-time ATR-FTIR spectroscopy, and the HV was measured on the top and bottom surfaces using a 300-gf load for 8 s (n = 5) after 24 h. The SS, DC, and HV differed significantly among the RBCs (p < 0.001). At 1400 s, Cention Forte developed the lowest stress (1.44 MPa), whereas Bulk EZ Plus and Fill-Up! produced the highest stress (3.77 MPa). The self-cured materials continued to develop measurable stress between 1400 s and 4000 s, while the light-cured RBCs had stabilized at 1400 s. Bulk EZ Plus and Stela produced the highest DC values, and Stela had the highest HV.