Augmented reality (AR) has been successfully providing surgeons an extensive visual information of surgical anatomy to assist them throughout the procedure. AR allows surgeons to view surgical field through the superimposed 3D virtual model of anatomical details. However, open surgery presents new challenges. This study provides a comprehensive overview of the available literature regarding the use of AR in open surgery, both in clinical and simulated settings. In this way, we aim to analyze the current trends and solutions to help developers and end/users discuss and understand benefits and shortcomings of these systems in open surgery. We performed a PubMed search of the available literature updated to January 2018 using the terms (1) “augmented reality” AND “open surgery”, (2) “augmented reality” AND “surgery” NOT “laparoscopic” NOT “laparoscope” NOT “robotic”, (3) “mixed reality” AND “open surgery”, (4) “mixed reality” AND “surgery” NOT “laparoscopic” NOT “laparoscope” NOT “robotic”. The aspects evaluated were the following: real data source, virtual data source, visualization processing modality, tracking modality, registration technique, and AR display type. The initial search yielded 502 studies. After removing the duplicates and by reading abstracts, a total of 13 relevant studies were chosen. In 1 out of 13 studies, in vitro experiments were performed, while the rest of the studies were carried out in a clinical setting including pancreatic, hepatobiliary, and urogenital surgeries. AR system in open surgery appears as a versatile and reliable tool in the operating room. However, some technological limitations need to be addressed before implementing it into the routine practice.

Benefits of minimally invasive neurosurgery mandate the development of ergonomic paradigms for neuronavigation. Augmented Reality (AR) systems can overcome the shortcomings of commercial neuronavigators. The aim of this work is to apply a novel AR system, based on a head-mounted stereoscopic video see-through display, as an aid in complex neurological lesion targeting. Effectiveness was investigated on a newly designed patient-specific head mannequin featuring an anatomically realistic brain phantom with embedded synthetically created tumors and eloquent areas. A two-phase evaluation process was adopted in a simulated small tumor resection adjacent to Broca's area. Phase I involved nine subjects without neurosurgical training in performing spatial judgment tasks. In Phase II, three surgeons were involved in assessing the effectiveness of the AR-neuronavigator in performing brain tumor targeting on a patient-specific head phantom. Phase I revealed the ability of the AR scene to evoke depth perception under different visualization modalities. Phase II confirmed the potentialities of the AR-neuronavigator in aiding the determination of the optimal surgical access to the surgical target. The AR-neuronavigator is intuitive, easy-to-use, and provides three-dimensional augmented information in a perceptually-correct way. The system proved to be effective in guiding skin incision, craniotomy, and lesion targeting. The preliminary results encourage a structured study to prove clinical effectiveness. Moreover, our testing platform might be used to facilitate training in brain tumour resection procedures.

The growing availability of self-contained and affordable augmented reality headsets such as the Microsoft HoloLens is encouraging the adoption of these devices also in the healthcare sector. However, technological and human-factor limitations still hinder their routine use in clinical practice. Among them, the major drawbacks are due to their general-purpose nature and to the lack of a standardized framework suited for medical applications and devoid of platform-dependent tracking techniques and/or complex calibration procedures. To overcome such limitations, in this paper we present a software framework that is designed to support the development of augmented reality applications for custom-made headmounted displays designed to aid high-precision manual tasks. The software platform is highly configurable, computationally efficient, and it allows the deployment of augmented reality applications capable to support in situ visualization of medical imaging data. The framework can provide both optical and video seethrough-based augmentations and it features a robust optical tracking algorithm. An experimental study was designed to assess the efficacy of the platform in guiding a simulated task of surgical incision. In the experiments, the user was asked to perform a digital incision task, with and without the aid of the augmented reality headset. The task accuracy was evaluated by measuring the similarity between the traced curve and the planned one. The average error in the augmented reality tests was < 1 mm. The results confirm that the proposed framework coupled with the new-concept headset may boost the integration of augmented reality headsets into routine clinical practice.